Diane Rosenthal could not find the keys to her rental car.
It was a Thanksgiving Day one year after her brothers Cecil and David were gunned down in their beloved Squirrel Hill synagogue. The family turned the house upside down looking for the keys, Ms. Rosenthal said, to no avail.

As they sat on the couch — the couch they’d already torn apart looking for the missing keys — someone lifted a cushion.
There were the keys.
“Someone said, ‘That’s probably David.’”
He was, after all, the trickster among the siblings.
Monday marked the start of the final phase in the trial of Pittsburgh synagogue shooter Robert Bowers. It is really the only part that has been in question since the trial began in earnest May 30: If Bowers will live or be sentenced to death.
Prosecutors for the government say the only real way to punish Bowers — to hold him accountable — is for him to die.
The defense team reminded jurors that they have no obligation to vote for death, and just one of them can send their client to prison for the rest of his life.
Defense attorneys face a tall task, experts have said. Their mitigation evidence — tales of his troubled childhood, his violent relationship with his parents, his history of depression and trauma — will be stacked against the tearful and heart-wrenching victim impact statements from the loved ones left behind when Bowers tore through the synagogue that morning.
More than four years have passed since Bowers stormed the synagogue at the corner of Shady and Wilkins avenues on Oct. 27, 2018. Three congregations were in the midst of Shabbat services: Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light.
Eleven worshippers were killed: Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax, and Irving Younger.
In June, jurors convicted him on all 63 charges against him. On Thursday, they decided he was eligible for the death penalty.
Several jurors wiped at tears as Ms. Rosenthal talked of her life with her brothers, Cecil and David, both whom were born with the genetic condition fragile X syndrome and thus lived with intellectual and physical disabilities.
She was the middle sister between her two brothers: Cecil was 59 when he was killed, she was 57, and David was 54. Another sister, Michelle, was still in her 40s in 2018.
Attitudes were different in the 1960s when her brothers were born, Ms. Rosenthal said, and doctors recommended time and again that her parents institutionalize their sons.
“It was really important to my parents that we all grow up in the same household,” Ms. Rosenthal said.
Cecil was the talker, she said, even from a young age. As she and other neighborhood kids in Stanton Heights played kick the can and kickball, Cecil would be on the porch with their mother and the other neighborhood ladies, talking and gossiping.
David was shyer, more reserved, she said — until he got to know someone.
“He wanted to be part of the group,” she said.
He was more athletic than Cecil, Ms. Rosenthal said, and she would drag him along during neighborhood games. He didn’t always get the rules, she said. He was just happy to be there.
As adults, they were doting uncles to her two daughters, though they didn’t quite understand the differences between aunts, uncles, nieces, nephews. They were gentle and loving all the same.
It has been particularly hard on her parents, she said. Neither are emotionally or physically capable of attending the trial, but the boys’ mother recorded a statement that was played for jurors.
“A big part of me died on Oct. 27, 2018,” she said in the recorded statement. “I woke up in the morning with two loving sons. I went to bed at night with only memories.”
It was a common theme among the family members who testified: immeasurable loss caused by lives cut suddenly and violently short.
Carol Black and her brother, Richard Gottfried, were just 15 months apart. They both went to the University of Pittsburgh, and attending Pitt games together became a tradition. One of the photos Ms. Black offered to jurors to capture her brother as a person was of the two of them at Heinz Field, posing together on the rotunda with the casino in the background.
Another showed her brother smiling easily at the camera, caught in a moment of near candidness. He’s wearing a red crewneck sweatshirt and a ball cap.
“If you look at this picture, you can just see who he is,” Ms. Black said.
Richard was the one who said the prayers before meals at the high holidays, Ms. Black said. He’s the one who reintroduced her to her faith, and he took on a leadership role within the New Light Congregation. He was the one who prayed before the Passover Seder.
“He’s not here to do that anymore,” she said.
His wife, Peg Durachko, met her husband when they were both in dental school. She took notice of him early on, she said, but it wasn’t until a few years later when he asked her for a ride home that she realized she’d apparently caught his eye, too.
They opened a dental practice together in 1984, and they ran it until he died.
“Half of me was gone,” she said. “I closed it.”
He had a motto, she said: We’re going to do this while we can.
“I’m so glad he said that,” she said, voice cracking. “At least I have those memories.”
A photo of Jodi Kart and her father, Melvin Wax, showed Ms. Kart as a small infant in her father’s arms. He looked at her glowing and smiling, completely taken with his daughter.
That look summed it up, she said. He didn’t always verbalize how much he cared for her, his only child, but he showed it. He took her to work with him on Saturdays when she was growing up, and they’d each lunch together.
When she went to his apartment after he was killed, she found a birthday card he’d already bought for her on his nightstand. In it, he’d written: “I love you very much.”
He was a proud man who went to school on the G.I. Bill and never bought something he didn’t need. If his watch stopped, he bought a new battery. If the leather wristband frayed, he bought a new wristband. If the leather on his shoes was still good, she said, he’d resole them rather than buy new ones.
Ms. Kart said she had many uncles who lived into their 90s. She’s left not knowing how many years her dad might have had left.
“I think of him every day,” she said.
In a similar vein, Pittsburgh police Officer Anthony Burke, too, thinks of Oct. 27, 2018, most days. The day of the shooting, he was shot in the hand trying to rescue downed officer Tim Matson. One surgery turned into three after he continued to suffer nerve damage that doctors just couldn’t fix.
He didn’t return to work for more than a year. Each day until then, he said, he thought about his fellow officers and longed to return to the line of duty.
Officer Burke said he became cynical, a recluse — “I just wanted to be inside and not talk about anything.”
Even after three surgeries, he continues to struggle with fine motor skills, and he has lingering weakness and numbness. He’ll probably never throw a football with a spiral again, he said. He was never good at shooting hoops, but he certainly isn’t now.
More importantly, he can’t release the magazine of his service weapon with his right hand — that’s even after having to learn to shoot all over again.
It was tough, he said.
Did he feel depressed, Assistant U.S. Attorney Soo C. Song asked?
Yes.
Does it linger today?
His voice cracked. Yes.
With emotion in his voice, the officer held back tears. He said he worries that, with his hand weakness and numbness and lack of dexterity, he feels he could “let his teammates down someday.”
‘A verdict of justice’
Assistant U.S. Attorney Nicole Vasquez Schmitt did not pull punches in her opening pitch to jurors, who are in their sixth week of hearing evidence and testimony at this point.
“You found him guilty. You found him eligible for the death penalty,” she said. “Now it is time to hold him accountable for his decisions.”
And they were just that, she said: Decisions. There were no delusions, no compulsions, no mental illness hindering his ability to form the intent and to know what he was doing. She told jurors that this was a premeditated attack six months in the making that left 11 people dead.
The shooter was proud of his carnage, Ms. Vasquez Schmitt said, but dismayed he didn’t kill more.
“Each of the 11 … is so much more than a victim of these horrific crimes,” she said. They left behind loved ones. The pain and the loss are staggering.”
She pointed to the four aggravating factors that jurors already agreed upon during the eligibility phase: he caused a grave risk to others, he killed multiple people, he planned the attack and some of those killed were particularly vulnerable.
Prosecutors will add to that, Ms. Vasquez Scmitt said, the impact the deaths had on their surviving family members, the impact on the injured survivors, Bowers’ espoused hatred of Jews, and his lack of remorse.
“Do not forget the violence and what he did to Joyce Fienberg, to Richard Gottfried, to Rose Mallinger, to Jerry Rabinowitz, to Cecil Rosenthal, to David Rosenthal, to Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Dan Stein, Melvin Wax, and Irving Younger,” she said. “Do not forget what he did to those 11 unique individuals, because that is what this case is about.”
She called upon the jurors to return a verdict of death — “a verdict of justice.”
Ms. Long, however, told jurors that Bowers’ death will not change reality.
“The great tragedy is that nothing that happens in the courtroom can turn back the clock,” she said. “Nothing can undo the harm that Mr. Bowers has caused.”
She laid out the case that the defense team will make once prosecutors have called all of their witnesses and presented all of their testimony. For nearly 40 minutes, she took jurors through an overview of blow after blow that Bowers suffered throughout his childhood, beginning before he was even born.
His parents were unstable, mentally ill, Ms. Long said. His father pushed his mother down a flight of stairs when she was 8 months pregnant. He once turned on the gas in their apartment and threatened to kill himself and the 6-month-old Bowers — right around the same time Bowers’ mother threatened to throw him from a third-floor window.
Depression and instability marked his infant years, even after his parents’ divorce before he was a year old, Ms. Long said. At 3, his mother moved him to Florida with a man she’d just met. Both she and the man, who would become Bowers’ stepfather, had stints in psychiatric facilities for depression and other mental illness.
When he was 7, his biological father was charged with rape. He killed himself with a shotgun in a Pennsylvania state park the day before he was set to go to trial.
Teachers raised red flags, but Bowers’ mother quashed each attempt to intervene, Ms. Long said. He spent most of age 13 in psychiatric hospitals after several attempts to kill himself. He’d make multiple attempts again — and spend more time in psychiatric facilities — throughout his teenage years.
“The accumulation of negative and toxic life circumstances are likely to result in negative outcomes in adulthood,” Ms. Long said.
From the domestic violence to the neglect, all of it came together to form a broken man who continued into the depths of instability and isolation in adulthood. It made him particularly susceptible to the vicious dribble spewed online about Jews and the fake terror they were bringing on the “white race.”
“The question of whether Mr. Bowers lives or dies is not a simple and not an easy one. We ask that you all keep an open mind,” Ms. Long said. “There has already been enough death, and another death will not make things right.”
Court resumes Tuesday at 9 a.m.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.