Last month, Aspinwall and Sharpsburg Volunteer Fire Departments announced they will merge under the name Southern Allegheny Valley Emergency Services — a move that will impact over 5,000 residents the combined municipalities serve.

The merger means Aspinwall and Sharpsburg Volunteer fire departments will operate under the same budget, share fire equipment, report to one fire chief and respond to calls as a team. Neither firehouse has announced closing – though that has happened with other consolidations.

Aspinwall Council President Tim McLaughlin said he anticipates that eventually, this will help financially, such as by saving $2 million on fire equipment, although the amount both communities spend on fire departments right now has not yet changed significantly.

This move is not unique to Aspinwall and Sharpsburg. Because of financial and administrative upsides, municipalities across the country, including in Western Pennsylvania, have announced or considered consolidations of their respective fire and police departments.

Advertise with us
This is patch that Beaver County Regional Police Sgt. Derek Shipley wears on his shoulder on Thursday, July 13, 2023. Sgt. Shipley was previously a Baden officer for 13 years. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

While some mergers have created concerns among residents and staff over adequate service and organizational changes, experts and city officials say they can give departments more financial and resourceful options, leaving a positive effect on communities.

Consolidations operate differently depending on the municipalities collaborating with one another and the types of departments merging.

Volunteer fire departments, which make up about 90% of the state’s fire departments, are the most common departments to consolidate, University of Pittsburgh public policy professor George Dougherty said.

He said one reason for the regionalization of fire departments is the declining number of volunteer firefighters in Pennsylvania, from over 300,000 in the 1970’s to about 38,000 today. This often leads to missed emergency calls, slower response times and a lack of firefighters on call who can properly operate the equipment, he said.

Beaver County Regional Police Sgt. Derek Shipley outside of their offices in Conway on Thursday, July 13, 2023. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Mr. McLaughlin said collaboration, which Aspinwall and Sharpsburg departments were already doing, is a key part of the process.

Advertise with us

“The hardest part of this is the fire departments getting along and joining and making the calls and making sure the safety of the community is never at risk, and these guys did that swimmingly,” he said.

On the financial end, it was more complicated, he said. The two municipalities have to work together to see the best way to fairly distribute funding and resources, and the process will take about three or four years until the budget is operating as officials anticipated.

While Aspinwall and Sharpsburg have been able to collaborate with one another effectively, meeting to discuss issues such as ownership of fire equipment, consolidation efforts can run into troubles.

Chief John Atkinson of Seville Volunteer Fire Company in Ross Township said volunteerism is at a “crisis level” nationwide, but mergers often “look better on paper.” According to the University of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania holds less than 13% of the number of firefighters it had in the 1970s. Researchers are currently conducting a study to see if Ross Township should consolidate their eight volunteer fire departments.

Beaver County Regional Police Sgt. Derek Shipley on patrol in Conway on Thursday, July 13, 2023. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Because of loyalty to one department and the longer commute for some firefighters, two departments who have a staff of 20 will likely not finish a merger with 40 firefighters as not all of them will stay with the new unit, he said. Additionally, one department may have $10 million in savings while another is $1 million in debt and that creates conflict.

Advertise with us

Chief Atkinson also said he fears losing some of the camaraderie and pride of his department, but the ultimate job is to serve the public.

He said fire departments connect with the community through events, such as offering the fire house for monthly union meetings and escorting the high school football team to championships.

“When your neighborhood firehouse closes down, and you don't have those events that happen at the firehouse, that goes away and doesn't come back,” Chief Atkinson said.

Unlike volunteer firefighters, police officers are paid, meaning the community can have a greater impact on a police department’s decision to consolidate, Mr. Dougherty said.

Police department regionalization often happens in under-resourced communities, where many police officers are part-time and have to handle cases such as domestic disputes with little support staff, he said.

Advertise with us

Bruce Antkowiak, a law professor at St. Vincent College, said police departments specifically require a considerable capital investment, even if the police force is small.

“The idea is if two or three communities get together, combine their police forces, they can have a lesser capital expenditure to provide theoretically the same service,” Mr. Antkowiak said.

He said state federal grants are also sometimes more accessible to a department that demonstrates a larger geographic jurisdiction. But a consolidation of departments generally leads to less community input as to how police orient themselves to the needs of that community.

“It’s a constant struggle to achieve that right mix of local community contact, but large enough departments to be able to access the economies of scale to get the equipment, to get the training, to get the number of officers, to get the grants that will come with a larger geographic jurisdiction but without losing that local touch is very important in a lot of communities,” Mr. Antkowiak said.

While Mr. Antkowiak said he doesn’t believe the perfect mix has been found, he thinks people are searching and it will be found in case-by-case scenarios.

Advertise with us
Beaver County Regional Police Sgt. Derek Shipley, left, stops to chat with developer Ryan Eichhorn of Beaver, who is building new apartments in Baden, on Thursday, July 13, 2023. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

This year, Baden, Conway and Freedom in Beaver County formed the Beaver Valley Regional Police Department to serve the three municipalities, whose population totals about 7,800 residents. The regional department now has 11 full-time officers total. Equipment, such as police cruisers, was also combined.

Baden Borough Manager Elaine Rakovan said she has heard nothing but positive feedback from residents across the three areas. She said the regional department has faster response times and is more able to hire part-time officers to meet needs.

Sgt. Derek Shipley, who serves the regional department, said there have been no gaps in police coverage across the three municipalities. While working for the Baden police, he said it always felt like the department was behind the curve.

He said now, the regional department has a more streamlined operation and is able to provide officers with more training. But, he said it required a lot of effort to complete consolidation.

“When these other municipalities talk about regionalization, they need to understand that everybody needs to play together nicely and there has to be somebody willing to put in the amount of work and effort,” Sgt. Shipley said. “To me, that was just the key to the whole thing.”