Prosecutors in the case against Pittsburgh synagogue shooter Robert Bowers will make their final pitch to jurors today as to why the seven women and five men should find the convicted shooter eligible for the death penalty.

Defense attorneys for Bowers, too, will make their final pitch — that their client was too mentally ill to have truly formed the intent to kill 11 worshippers Oct. 27, 2018.

For more than two weeks, each side has made their case: Prosecutors arguing that evidence shows Bowers was calculated in his planning of the attack and knew what he was doing that morning, and defense attorneys offering evidence that Bowers wasn’t capable of premeditation or intent.

Jurors will likely begin deliberations this afternoon in this so-called eligibility phase.

Advertise with us

Just under a month ago, jurors convicted Bowers of all 63 federal charges against him. On June 26, the second phase of the trial, the penalty phase, began. The penalty phase takes place in two parts: First, jurors must decide if prosecutors proved that Bowers is eligible to receive the death penalty. If they find he is eligible, they will move to the sentence-selection phase where they must decide if he lives or dies.

The decision to find him eligible for the death penalty must be unanimous. If jurors cannot reach that unanimous decision, U.S. District Judge Robert Colville will sentence Bowers to life in prison.

The Squirrel Hill synagogue Bowers targeted housed three congregations: Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light. Those killed were Richard Gottfried, Joyce Fienberg, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax and Irving Younger.

To find Bowers eligible for the death penalty, jurors must agree that prosecutors proved two aspects: That Bowers could truly form the intent to kill and that the crime involved at least one of four aggravating factors.

Those aggravating factors can include that Bowers created a grave risk of death to others; the crime involved substantial planning and premeditation, those killed were particularly vulnerable because of their age or physical or intellectual disabilities; and there were multiple killings or attempted killings.

Advertise with us

The government’s initial testimony in the eligibility phase lasted only one day. Of the eight witnesses they called, six were family members of victims. Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Rose Mallinger, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax and Joyce Fienberg were all over the age of 70 when they were killed. Their ages made them particularly vulnerable, prosecutors said.

Cecil and David Rosenthal, while only in their 50s, suffered intellectual disabilities stemming from the genetic disorder called fragile X syndrome. Those circumstances rendered them particularly vulnerable, as well, the government said.

The bulk of the defense testimony — and the cross examination by prosecutors — focused on two other aspects considered aggravating factors: whether or not Bowers engaged in extensive planning and whether or not he had the capacity to form the intent to kill.

Defense experts testified that Bowers’ MRIs and EEGs showed abnormalities in his brain and its functions. Others testified that he showed signs of schizophrenia and delusions. The delusions, in this case, were his beliefs that immigrants were invading the country with aid from Jewish people, whom he also believed were killing children.

Last week, the government called its rebuttal witnesses — their own experts to testify to the opposite. It took more than three days for both sides to question and re-question the two rebuttal witnesses, both of whom said Bowers was neither delusional nor schizophrenic, and had the capacity to both plan and intentionally carry out his crimes.

Much of the cross examination of rebuttal witnesses was handled by defense attorney Michael N. Burt, who spent hours trying to cast doubt on the qualifications, testimony and truthfulness of rebuttal witnesses Dr. Ryan Darby and Dr. Park Dietz.