A Pennsylvania state court handed down a key decision that will allow autopsy and toxicology reports in Allegheny County to become public records, a move that will greatly expand open access to information about deaths in Allegheny County.

The Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania said on Tuesday that county officials must produce autopsy records for Daniel Pastorek, a 63-year-old inmate at the Allegheny County jail who died in November 2020.

The decision comes nearly three years after the director of the Pittsburgh Institute for Nonprofit Journalism sought to obtain county records about the death of the inmate to find out if the conditions in the jail contributed to his death. At the time of Brittany Hailer’s request, county officials said the inmate had died of heart disease.

“This is a big win for transparency,” said Melissa Melewsky, media law counsel at the Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association.

Advertise with us

Because Pastorek had no next-of-kin, and died in the custody of a public agency, “it falls to the community to figure out whether that death calls for a policy change at the county or state level,” she said. “The autopsy report is a critical tool.”

Since April 2020, more than a dozen inmates have died either at the county jail or a hospital nearby, leading to calls for the Allegheny County’s Jail Oversight Board to increase its scrutiny of the facility.

County officials have long argued that because of Allegheny County’s status as a second-class county — a distinction based on its larger population — it is exempt from the state’s Right-to-Know Law or Coroner’s Act. In 2021, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge W. Terrence O’Brien sided with the officials, allowing the reports to remain secret.

But in the majority opinion for the 6-1 decision, Commonwealth Judge Ellen Ceisler wrote that nothing in state law banned the release of the reports. "There is no language in the Right-to-Know Law or the Coroner’s Act to suggest that access to certain public records depends on the county class in which the records are located," Judge Ceisler wrote.

A spokesperson for the county Law Department said officials are “presently reviewing the decision” and “will assess the county’s options.”

Advertise with us

University of Pittsburgh law professor David Harris said the decision will advance Allegheny County’s standing nationally in terms of transparency, as Pennsylvania’s Right-to-Know laws are not as robust as other states.

Many states — such as Florida, Ohio, Maryland and New Jersey — have allowed autopsy records to be publicly accessible for years, usually upon the conclusion of a medical examiner’s investigation. In others, like West Virginia, the reports continue to be considered classified medical records with limited disclosure.

Overall, when compared to other states, Pennsylvania's public records law is underpinned by one crucial principle: the presumption that government records belong to the public, Ms. Melewsky said.

But she also pointed out that public records laws in the state allow for broad exceptions when it comes to records related to criminal and noncriminal investigations, putting the state “way below average” when it comes to transparency."

“Those are extremely problematic,” she said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Harris said the ruling will open the way for reporters and others to gather information in death cases where law enforcement is often the sole source.

"Too often, when somebody dies in police or jail custody as an example, we only have one story, and this can go some distance — in the same way that body camera video could and does in certain cases — to give the public a fuller account."

Mr. Harris, a longtime law enforcement scholar, said the ruling was “a positive move” that will expand transparency among law enforcement agencies in the county.

"Control of information can mean control of the narrative; it can mean control of the course of an investigation. And that can be used by people who have power, and that is not in the public interest generally.”

Michael Korsh: mkorsh@post-gazette.com; @michael_korsh.

Post-Gazette Assistant Managing Editor Mike Wereschagin contributed to this report.