Convicted Pittsburgh synagogue shooter Robert Bowers has an above-average IQ but is slow to process information and has trouble making social inferences, both of which point to possible brain dysfunction, an expert testified Monday.

Erin David Bigler, a now-retired Brigham Young University neuropsychologist who specializes in how behavior relates to brain anatomy, analyzed the data collected by other defense experts and some data collected by an expert for the prosecution.

That included myriad brain scans, including EEGs, PET scans, and MRIs.

Reviewing that data — most of which was presented last week by other experts testifying on behalf of the defense — he concluded that Bowers has brain deficiencies similar to those seen in others with schizophrenia.

Advertise with us

Jurors on June 16 convicted Bowers of all 63 federal charges against him. Those charges stemmed from the attack on the Squirrel Hill synagogue that housed the congregations Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light. Eleven were killed: Richard Gottfried, Joyce Fienberg, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax and Irving Younger.

Last week, the penalty phase of the trial began, which will happen in two parts. In this first part, jurors must decide if Bowers is eligible for the death penalty. Their decision hinges upon prosecutors proving that Bowers was capable of forming the intent to kill and that the crimes had at least one of four aggravating factors.

If jurors determine he is eligible for the death penalty, they will then hear evidence from both sides and ultimately decide if Bowers spends life in prison or is sent to death row.

Mr. Bigler said Bowers scored on the higher end in terms of intelligence quotient, or IQ. With a full scale score of 120, Mr. Bigler said, Bowers is in the 91st percentile.

Some of the subscales the full scale score is made up of also showed Bowers in an above-average percentile, including spatial reasoning.

Advertise with us

His processing speed — how quickly he takes in information — was an 86, or in the 18th percentile, though. That’s still in the average range, Mr. Bigler said, but it’s at the lower end of average and is far lower than one might expect it to be given his full scale score.

That, he said, is a sign Bowers’ brain “isn’t working quite the way it should.”

Mr. Bigler noted other deficiencies as well, including some related to memory and executive function.

Mr. Bigler’s testimony also touched on the white matter hyper-intensities or white matter lesions noted last week by other experts.

Dr. Murray Solomon, a neuroradiologist and the medical director of the Bay Area MRI Medical Partnership in Los Gatos, Calif., said he reviewed an MRI of Bowers performed by a UPMC facility in early 2022.

Advertise with us

His review revealed 28 white matter lesions. Gray matter, he explained, makes up the surface of the brain where the actual processing is done, whereas white matter is where the brain’s proverbial wiring is. In essence, white matter helps the different parts of the brain communicate with each other.

The lesions, he said, could be caused by a traumatic brain injury or other brain abnormalities, and they could generate epilepsy. They could also be the result of prolonged tobacco or drug use.

Mr. Bigler, in his testimony, said the white matter hyper-intensities show a connectivity issue and dysfunction in Bowers’ brain, especially between the frontal and temporal lobes and between the brain’s two hemispheres.

“There are neurological test results that show the temporal lobe is not functioning properly,” Mr. Bigler said.

The temporal lobe is located in the lower front part of the brain and is responsible for processing auditory information and memory. The frontal lobe, which is in the front of the brain as the name implies, controls motor function, expressive language and most higher-level executive functioning. Executive functions include planning and organizing, self-monitoring and self-control, reasoning and problem-solving.

Advertise with us

He noted, though, that there is no diagnostic test for schizophrenia.

U.S. Attorney Eric Olshan cross examined Mr. Bigler for around 90 minutes. Part of his focus was on the fact that Mr. Bigler relied only on the work other experts and did not do any of his own independent analysis.

He also noted that Mr. Bigler’s first report, written in June 2022, relied on defense attorneys telling him that other professionals had given Bowers a “working diagnosis” of schizophrenia. Mr. Bigler authored a second report last weekend that included his take on data collected by a prosecution witness the government now has no intent to call for rebuttal.

The defense intends to rest its case in this stage of the trial when court resumes on Wednesday. After that, the government will call two rebuttal witnesses. Assistant U.S. Attorney Soo C. Song told U.S. District Judge Robert J. Colville the hope is to complete the rebuttal testimony in less than two days.

Court is in session only two more days this week: Wednesday and Thursday.