Convicted synagogue shooter Robert Bowers saw himself as a soldier fighting back in what he believed to be a war on the “white race” — a belief so strong he had to act upon it, despite incontrovertible evidence to the contrary.
He told Texas-based forensic psychologist Richard Rogers that as he gunned down congregants at a Squirrel Hill synagogue in 2018, he was thinking, “You Jews want a war on white people, you deserved it.”

Mr. Rogers, who has more than 30 years’ experience at the University of North Texas, returned to the stand Friday morning after a full day of testimony the day prior.
Jurors earlier this month convicted Bowers, 50, of all 63 federal charges he faced in connection with the shooting. The synagogue housed three congregations: Tree of Life, Dor Hadash, and New Light. Eleven were killed: Richard Gottfried, Joyce Fienberg, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax, Irving Younger.
In this phase of the trial, jurors must decide if Bowers is eligible for the death penalty. To find him as such, jurors must believe prosecutors successfully proved Bowers had intent and the crime had at least one aggravating factor.
For two days, Mr. Rogers was the only witness on the stand. He was dismissed shortly before 3 p.m. Friday. Bickering between sides about the content of a Powerpoint presentation set to be shown by the next witness led U.S. District Judge Robert J. Colville to end the day early.
Jurors cheered.
Throughout the morning and afternoon, defense attorney Michael Burt and U.S. Attorney Eric Olshan went back and forth with Mr. Rogers again, asking him extensively about his report diagnosing Bowers with schizophrenia but more so about notes he took during his four meetings with Bowers last year.
Mr. Olshan hammered the pieces of information the psychologist kept out of his report, like Bowers’ references to wanting “messy kills” and covering up the extra ammunition he had in his passenger seat the morning of the shooting.
Mr. Burt, on re-direct examination Friday morning, also took Mr. Rogers back through his notes — even more extensively than Mr. Olshan had the day prior. He asked Mr. Rogers if it would be prudent to include everything he’d examined and everything Bowers had said in his final report.
He said it would not be.
“I was being selective,” he said. “Hitting the key points.”
Mr. Rogers again spoke about the myriad exams and tests performed to bring him to his diagnosis and his belief that Bowers suffers from severe delusions, particularly in regard to one test that showed Bowers scored in the “normal” range in terms of schizophrenia.
The psychologist said that was because Bowers has no insight into his own illness.
“He normalized his delusional thoughts,” he said.
For example, he pointed to one question Bowers answered about himself: “My thinking has become confused.” Out of possible answers of “false,” “somewhat true,” “mainly true” and “very true,” Bowers selected “false.”
That’s despite the fact that Bowers clearly had disordered thinking and disordered thoughts, Mr. Rogers said, noting he often couldn’t follow Bowers’ train of thought or find the logic in it. Some of those thoughts included references to white genocide, a great fire, angels and aliens and battling against satan and Jewish people.
Mr. Olshan asked Mr. Rogers if he was familiar with the theory of white genocide of the so-called white genocide manifesto, which he said includes tropes Bowers referred to. The witness said he wasn’t aware of the manifesto, nor had he done extensive research into the beliefs of white supremacists.
The prosecutor was trying to purport that what Mr. Rogers deemed as delusions are actually white supremacist beliefs held by others as well.
Friday’s testimony hit many of the same points from the day prior, when Mr. Olshan asked Mr. Rogers if all white supremacists who shared those beliefs were delusional.
“We’re talking about the severity of the beliefs and the actions taken for the beliefs,” Mr. Rogers said.
Defense attorneys used myriad points from Mr. Rogers’ report and notes to back up their argument that Bowers is too mentally ill to have formed a real intent to kill. Prosecutors are using those same points to bolster their claims that Bowers clearly reasoned and planned his way to Oct. 27, 2018.
For example, Bowers had apparently planned to attack the synagogue one week prior. He’d checked the schedules at the synagogue and knew there might be children present on Oct. 20. The psychologist’s notes indicated Bowers had “thought about it” and changed his mind, noting that killing children wouldn’t be good for “optics.”
Bowers had also considered other targets, according to his interviews with Mr. Rogers, including a specific woman in Cleveland and the two local Jewish Community Centers — one in Scott and the other on Forbes Avenue in Squirrel Hill.
Mr. Rogers, however, said Thursday he believed Bowers was suffering from a severe mental illness when he stormed the synagogue, which left him unable to truly weigh the risks and consequences of his delusional thinking.
“He did not just believe [his conduct] to be correct,” Mr. Rogers said, “he believed it absolutely had to be done.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.