A local educator and frequent attendee of the Allegheny County Jail Oversight Board meetings has filed a lawsuit against that body, alleging that it has violated the state’s open meetings law.

The suit, filed by Rachel Radke in the county’s Court of Common Pleas, was first reported on by Pittsburgh City Paper, and recently by WESA. In it, Ms. Radke sues the chair of the board, Judge Elliot Howsie, along with Judge Beth Lazzara, in their official capacities. She has also sued the Jail Oversight Board as a whole.

Ms. Radke alleges that the board has been violating the state’s Sunshine Act, the name covering public meetings laws in the Pennsylvania. Specifically, she points to multiple instances where she believes the board broke the law.

Ms. Radke could not immediately be reached for comment by phone Tuesday.

Advertise with us

During its meeting on May 18, the board voted to make Karen Duffola, a former drug court coordinator for Allegheny County, its liaison to the county jail. The lawsuit states that this action was illegal because the motion to appoint Ms. Duffola was not listed on the public agenda for the meeting. She could not immediately be reached for comment Tuesday.

Ms. Radke also alleges that people giving public comment at the meetings are restricted to three minutes, unlike the five-minute period listed on the county’s website. The suit also states that board members and jail Warden Orlando Harper have been discussing subjects in executive session that could be addressed in an open meeting. It says that when at-large council member Bethany Hallam -- who also sits on the jail oversight board -— tries to ask Mr. Harper questions, he incorrectly says that they can only be discussed during executive session.

The lawsuit also alleges that Judge Howsie is instructing attendees not to ask questions of board members or jail staff during the public comment period—those being questioned do not have to respond, but must allow inquiries, per the Sunshine Act.

The county’s Jail Oversight Board has held multiple meetings that have turned contentious in recent months. At a meeting on June 8, Judge Howsie and other members of the board walked out of the meeting after multiple attendees stood up and started softly singing, “Mama, Mama, can't you see what the system’s done to me?”

When there was no longer a quorum, Judge Lazzara told Ms. Hallam that the board could not complete agenda items on its list. Ms. Hallam had said earlier in the meeting that Judge Howsie’s motion to adjourn the meeting was not seconded, and thus that the meeting should not have ended.

Advertise with us

Jail Oversight Board meetings typically occur on the first Thursday of every month. The agenda for July’s meeting has not yet been posted.

Correction, posted June 20, 2023: This story has been updated to clarify the lawsuit fell under the state’s Sunshine Act, which covers open meetings.