Less than two hours before Robert Bowers walked into a Squirrel Hill synagogue with a rifle and three handguns, he once more visited the website for the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society, a Jewish faith-based refugee resettlement organization.

Minutes before he walked in — about 9:49 a.m. Oct. 27, 2018 — he posted to the alt-right social media website Gab: "HIAS likes to bring invaders in that kill our people. I can't sit by and watch my people get slaughtered. Screw your optics, I'm going in.”

The “in” was the synagogue on the corner of Shady and Wilkins aveues where three congregations worshipped: Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light. Congregation Dor Hadash had recently participated in HIAS’ refugee Shabbat program, and the congregation’s involvement was listed on the HIAS website.

“Optics” refer to a split among white supremacists, said William Braniff, a Department of Homeland Security employee and University of Maryland professor. On Tuesday, the 10th full day of testimony in the death penalty trial against Mr. Bowers, prosecutors introduced Mr. Braniff as an expert in hate crimes and white supremacy.

Advertise with us

The prosecution will likely rest its case Wednesday afternoon.

Defense attorney Michael Burt pushed back against Mr. Braniff’s expert designation, cross examining him about his areas of expertise — including international terrorism until the rise of the white supremacy movement in recent years — for a lengthy period.

U.S. District Judge Robert Colville allowed Mr. Braniff to testify as an expert.

“The optics debate is a discussion among modern white supremacist regarding what is the best way to advance the popularity of their goals. There are some that argue on the one extreme that the white supremacist movement needs to engage in violence,” he said, while others suggest they should “take a much lower profile.”

Mr. Bowers faces 63 federal charges related to the shooting that killed 11 people: Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax, Irving Younger.

Advertise with us

Mr. Braniff did not label Mr. Bowers as a white supremacist or testify that he was part of any movement; rather, he combed through thousands of Gab posts, reposts and “likes” posted in relation to them and identified keywords and images associated with the hate group.

In his more than 600 Gab posts between early January 2018 and Oct. 27, 2018, the word “Jew” appeared 152 times, according to FBI specialist Evan Browne. An antisemtic slur for Jewish people appeared 87 times. He mentioned “oven” 21 times, and HIAS 15 times. He mentioned “immigrant,” “invader,” “refugee,” and “illegals” a combined 22 times.

In his nine months on the platform, Mr. Bowers “liked” more than 19,000 posts made by other Gab users. They called for genocide against Jewish people, called them a cancer, a plague, and dirty, filthy rats. The posts praised German Nazi leader Adolph Hitler and denied that the Holocaust ever happened — but it should, the posts read.

“Jew” appeared 2,372 times in those 19,000 liked posts.

The afternoon closed with a shooting reconstruction expert from the FBI. He spoke about the trajectory of the myriad bullet holes and strike marks throughout the synagogue. He pointed to how the high-powered, small-caliber rifle rounds could penetrate wooden banisters and rows of wooden pews. One round struck a prayer book in a holder on the back of a pew. The round went through the book with such power that the book was found on the floor two rows back.

Advertise with us

Testimony will resume Wednesday morning.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Soo C. Song said the government has only four more witnesses to call, and she anticipates they will rest their case Wednesday afternoon.

It was unclear who those witnesses might be. It was also not clear what witnesses, if any, Mr. Bowers’ defense attorneys would call to the stand.

In a late Monday filing, defense attorneys representing Mr. Bowers accused prosecutors of violating federal rules of evidence, alleging an FBI agent and Assistant U.S. Attorney listened in on interviews related to Mr. Bowers’ court-ordered psychiatric evaluation.

Days before testimony began in the case, Judge Colville ruled that a government-retained expert could evaluate the defendant.

Advertise with us

The issue had been a source of bickering between prosecutors and defense attorneys, and neither side could agree to a set of provisions dictating the format and circumstances of the evaluation; chiefly, whether defense attorneys could observe the evaluation either in person or virtually.

Prosecutors had argued that allowing defense counsel to observe the exam “would provide the defense an unwarranted preview of the government’s mental health rebuttal.”

Judge Colville ultimately ruled that no attorney from either side could be present during the examinations, nor could prosecutors discuss the examinations with their expert unless or until a guilty verdict was rendered.

“Against this backdrop, however, it is clear that at least one of the government’s experts has been in communication with at least two members of the government trial team and has indeed permitted [them] to observe part of his evaluation of Mr. Bowers,” defense attorneys wrote in a filing Monday night.

Defense attorneys alleged reports turned over by the prosecution indicated that FBI Agent Samantha Bell, the case agent and an “integral part” of the prosecution, and Assistant U.S. Attorney Nicole Vasquez Schmitt listened in on telephone interviews conducted by government expert Dr. Park Dietz with three Butler County Prison employees. Mr. Bowers is being housed in that facility.

Advertise with us

Those employees are considered “collateral witnesses” in regard to Dr. Dietz’s psychiatric evaluation in that the interview focused on “mental health symptoms and behaviors” they observed in Mr. Bowers.

“By arranging for one of its trial lawyers and its case agent to be present during these interviews, the government has done precisely what it fought so hard and so successfully to prevent defense counsel from doing,” Mr. Bowers’ counsel wrote, chiefly “access a portion of the expert’s evaluation process prior to the conclusion of the guilt phase of the trial.”

Prosecutors must respond by 9 a.m. Wednesday.