Through four full days of testimony, prosecutors have called nearly two dozen witnesses in the trial against accused Pittsburgh synagogue shooter Robert Bowers.
The defense has cross-examined three of them, all for no more than a minute or two.
Otherwise, defense attorney Judy Clarke has simply smiled and thanked the witness for their time.

“The defense is not going to be asking questions. Why would you?” said Bruce Antkowiak, a former federal prosecutor and defense attorney who teaches at St. Vincent College in Latrobe. “There is not dispute about what happened. The last thing you want to do is make the jury think you are in some way challenging the testimony of these people.”
Jurors have heard grueling testimony, much of it from survivors who made it out of the synagogue. Tree of Life Rabbi Jeffrey Myers testified about how he gripped the doorknob of a small bathroom for more than 40 minutes, remaining on the phone with a 911 call taker the entire time.
“I expected to die,” he testified Tuesday, weeping. “I was trying to decide, ‘Do I hang up the phone and call my wife or make a video?’ I thought if this was the end, I wasn’t going to leave her like that, for her to hear that. So I decided to stay on the phone with 911.”
Read More
Eleven congregants were killed inside the Squirrel Hill synagogue when the accused gunman stormed Shabbat services and opened fire with an AR-15-style rifle on Oct. 27, 2018: Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax and Irving Younger.
Three congregations worshipped in the building at the corner of Shady and Wilkins avenues.
Dan Leger, too, told jurors that he expected to die. The Dor Hadash congregant heard a loud crash the morning of the shooting and ran toward the sound. He was shot in the abdomen and lay dying on a stairwell for 45 minutes. He told them about looking back on his life and making peace with death. He looked up and saw a camo pant leg that he later found out belonged to a SWAT paramedic.
“I remember thinking either this is a helper or it’s the shooter,” Mr. Leger testified. “Either way, I had nothing to lose.”
Mr. Antkowiak said that the trail of graphic, emotional evidence is all calculated by prosecutors. They know there is almost zero doubt that Mr. Bowers will be found guilty. They want the jurors to see that Mr. Bowers’ has crossed a line in society that dictates the harshest of punishments.
The guilt phase of the trial — expected to last around three weeks — is essentially just extra time for prosecutors to make their point that Mr. Bowers should be sentenced to die.
“This is a very, very odd case in certain respects because there is no dispute about what happened or who was responsible,” Mr. Antkowiak said. “That issue usually is the centerpiece of many, many cases, and that is not at all even a consideration here.”
Indeed, Ms. Clarke used her opening statements to make a point.
“The loss that occurred is immeasurable, this senseless act,” she told jurors Tuesday morning. “The loss and devastation caused by Robert Bowers. There is no disagreement, no dispute and there will be no doubt who shot and killed the 11 congregants and wounded several others. There will be no question that this was a planned attack and Robert Bowers killed 11 and wounded seven others.”
But, she said, “These are federal charges, not straightforward murder charges,” and each has certain elements that have to be proven.
Mr. Bowers, 50, faces 63 federal charges, including hate crime-related counts, and the prospect of the death penalty.
Ms. Clarke told the jurors they will have to examine Mr. Bowers’ motives and intentions — and the evidence behind them. He was at the synagogue that day, she said, to stop the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society, a Jewish group that helped resettle refugees. She said those refugees, in his mind, were invaders.
Mr. Antkowiak said that’s likely not something the defense will hang on to as the trial goes on.
“If you were trying this case to a judge alone, that might be a viable point to me,” he said. “To a jury who has seen these pictures, who have heard these stories of the people who survived — deaf ears. It will fall on deaf ears that will react very badly to a notion that there is some technical defense to what happened here.”
One caveat, he said, would be if that idea plays into testimony about Mr. Bowers’ capacity to form intent — that is, his incapacities didn’t even allow him to equate this to a hate crime in his own mind.
The jury of 11 women and seven men — 12 jurors and six alternates — will likely hear at least two more weeks of testimony in the guilt phase of the trial. If Mr. Bowers is found guilty, jurors will decide if he is eligible for the death penalty and, if they decide he is, deliberate as to whether he should spend life in prison or be executed.
Mr. Antkowiak said he’d be surprised if the defense offers any evidence after the prosecution rests.
“I would seriously expect nothing,” he said, reiterating that the defense team does not want to convey “in any way, shape or form” that Mr. Bowers’ guilt is in dispute.
That’s a critical point, he said, assuming the strategy is to shift the jury’s focus entirely to the mitigation issues that will be brought up in sentencing.
The defense team has indicated they’ll present evidence regarding Mr. Bowers’ mental and neurological capabilities, noting in court filings earlier this year that their expert diagnosed him with schizophrenia, epilepsy and neurological abnormalities.
They will give jurors a thorough overview of Mr. Bowers’ life, including his childhood and social-psychological history — anything to show the events in his life that led up to the day he stormed the synagogue.
“Let that be the pure message that you send at the beginning, the middle and end of the trial: He did it, it’s terrible, it’s the worst thing that’s ever happened in Pittsburgh and it was done by a man who is as defective a human being as can be,” he said. “He’s not evil, he’s defective.”
A shootout, injured officers and a surrender
Much of Friday involved testimony from Pittsburgh police officers who responded to the synagogue in the minutes after horrified congregants began calling 911 from closets and bathrooms.
During testimony from the day prior, Dan Mead, the first officer to encounter Mr. Bowers, testified as to how he believed he would lose his hand after the rifle blast tore through it.
On Friday morning, his partner, Officer Michael Smidga, told jurors about taking cover after Officer Mead was shot. He slowly moved along the front wall of the synagogue, carefully past windows, believing the shooter was still looking for outside targets.
“From the shots I heard, he had a rifle and I had a pistol,” he said.
Moving down the outer wall, he came to a window. Furniture covered most of the window, but he could see through a sliver. He said he peered through and saw a hallway. Poking out of the door of the chapel that opened into that hallway, he saw the barrel of a rifle, then the rifle strap — and then the man holding the rifle.
“I saw that man over there,” Officer Smidga testified, pointing toward Mr. Bowers at the defense table. “I waited for this person to come fully into view, and I saw that man right there.”
He said the man looked at him. Officer Smidga started shooting through the window, then retreated to a small corner a few yards down. He said he didn’t know if he hit the shooter but, “I knew he was pissed.”
The officer eventually realized he was bleeding; the rifle blast had sent shrapnel and glass across the side of his head and face. He was examined by paramedics, then went back to work.
Officer Steve Mescan, a SWAT operator and tactical commander, was at the Zone 1 station on the city’s North Side when he heard the call. He made his way to Squirrel Hill “as fast as humanly possible” and began assessing the situation. He and other officers went room by room, ticking off the number of dead and checking for signs of life.
They got Andrea Wedner, daughter of Rose Mallinger, out and to a hospital.
On the top floor, SWAT officers entered one room and were met by a barrage of rifle fire. They didn’t realize at the time that it was the top floor or that they were nearing the last rooms in the “labyrinth of doorways and stairwells.”
Officer Tim Matson was hit multiple times. His fellow officers struggled to maneuver the large man through the narrow hallways and sharp corners. Officer Matson would eventually recover but nearly died from his wounds.
After another shootout, the injured Mr. Bowers called out that he wanted to surrender. He wanted medical treatment.
SWAT officer Clint Thimmons told the shooter he would have to come to them.
“Crawl out or you will die,” jurors heard Officer Thimmons say on the police radio recordings played in court.
“I wanted to be very direct,” he told them. “He needed to save himself.”
He eventually crawled out of the room, leaving a trail of blood behind him. As he did, he called out his name, his age and his date of birth. An officer asked why he did it. He relayed to officers that he was angry about “Jews” killing children.
While the shooter was receiving medical treatment, Officer Mescan sent Officer Thimmons to try to get info from Mr. Bowers — he sent him to tell Mr. Bowers they had video footage of him entering the synagogue with someone else.
Per Officer Mescan, Mr. Bowers replied with something along the lines of, “That must have been some [expletive] Jew. I did this all by myself.”
“He wanted to be very clear that he was by himself,” Officer Mescan said, “and this was his doing.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.