When George Floyd was killed at the hands of Minneapolis police three years ago, many thought this country’s reckoning with racial justice and policing had finally come.

Protests swept across the United States, with thousands taking to the streets in protest to demand justice and accountability for Floyd and other people of color killed by police. For many, the moment for real conversations -- and real change -—surrounding racism in policing was long overdue.

Fast forward three years, when the nation has weathered a global pandemic, multiple natural disasters, a contentious political cycle and economic uncertainty, and the major police reforms many had hoped for have largely not materialized.

The beating death of Tyre Nichols at the hands of Memphis police officers in early January has underscored just how long it could take.

Advertise with us

So what has changed since a Minneapolis police officer kneeled on Floyd’s neck for more nine minutes on May 25, 2020? Post-Gazette reporters talked to teachers, legal experts, coaches and those in the mental health and arts communities about what they’ve seen, and what they hope the future brings.

A button that reads "I can't breathe," adorns the jacket of a mourner before the funeral for George Floyd on Tuesday, June 9, 2020, in Houston. (Godofredo A. Vásquez / Houston Chronicle via AP, Pool, File)

‘People with guns and handcuffs aren’t the right choice’

Read More

The murder of Floyd at the hands of police — a murder that was seen the world over — opened up the opportunity for there to be a watershed moment in policing. Did society meet that moment? Yes and no, said University of Pittsburgh law professor David Harris.

“We have had real change — not as much as some people hoped, and more than others wanted or thought was necessary. And not as much change as we need,” he said. “But there has been some.”

He pointed to a rise in the creation of and support for so-called co-responder models — that is, involving non-police responders in situations that aren’t criminal. Recognizing that some situations, like those involving mental health crises, homelessness and addiction, don’t need a police response is a move in the right direction, Mr. Harris said.

Advertise with us

“People with guns and handcuffs aren’t the right choice, and they don’t have the right tools,” he said. “Instead, we need mental health workers, medics, etc.”

In 2021, then-Mayor Bill Peduto’s administration launched the Office of Community Health and Safety with the goal of adding social workers, mental health experts and others to certain public safety responses.

“Police officers, paramedics, EMTs, and firefighters spend a significant portion of time responding to non-emergent calls involving mental and behavioral health conditions, homelessness, and substance use,” reads the office’s description. “While first responders have adapted to these circumstances, we recognize that the complex needs (of these) individuals can only be met when we send the right responder to assist them.”

The former mayor, in the aftermath of Floyd’s death, also created the Task Force on Police Reform, which spent months creating a list of policy and guideline changes they believed could change policing for the better. Many targeted use of force, Mr. Harris said, and many were adopted into Pittsburgh’s police policy.

“Much more is needed, particularly at the state level,” he said, noting that Pennsylvania “still uses the old concepts” that date back to 1980s Supreme Court decisions.

Advertise with us

There have been other changes in the three years since Floyd’s death, too, Mr. Harris said.

The liability surrounding Floyd’s death extended beyond just the officer who kneeled on his neck for nearly nine minutes. Three other Minneapolis officers were convicted of violating Floyd’s civil rights when they failed to intervene in then-Officer Derek Chauvin’s behavior and again when they failed to render aid.

Those officers’ inactions sparked changes in police training and policy that mandate peer bystander intervention, Mr. Harris said, and such trainings have the potential to stop misconduct and excessive force.

But, he said, there remains work to do.

“Much more needs to be done to ensure police accountability and transparency,” he said, calling state laws “woefully out of touch.”

Advertise with us

“Discipline for misconduct is often inconsistent, spotty, and invisible to the public,” he said. “That prevents real accountability and undermines public confidence.”

Megan Guza: mguza@post-gazette.com and Twitter: @MeganGuzaPG

__

Schools tackle difficult conversations

As districts and students across the country grappled with multiple cases of brutality against Black people in 2020 discussions arose about making curriculums more inclusive and the role of police in school buildings .

Advertise with us

Across the region, two Pittsburgh Public Schools principals organized a march that drew about 500 people, including teachers, administrators and city residents. School directors sought more information about interactions between students and police inside city schools.

Educators and supporters raise their hands in support of change, at the entrance of Pittsburgh Colfax K-8, at the end of their Peaceful March, Monday, June 8, 2020, in Squirrel of Pittsburgh. The March started at 8:46 a.m. in Point Breeze, to stand also for the length of time that it took for the death of George Floyd in police custody. (Darrell Sapp / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

At Penn Hills, administrators looked at an already existing partnership with municipal police and sought ways to improve relationships between officers and students. The district has over 3,000 students, almost 64% of whom are Black. Of students in the district, almost 63% are economically disadvantaged.

“This case and the many others that are so tragic really reinforces the school’s obligation to help kids and police officers become more comfortable with one another,” Penn Hills Superintendent Nancy Hines said.

Through the partnership, active duty Penn Hills police officers are placed in each of the district’s school buildings. They are part of a multi-layered security system, and only respond to incidents as a last resort. Instead, officers have the opportunity to interact with students and build relationships to help de-escalate situations.

For many officers, that partnership means spending time eating lunch with students or playing basketball and participating in other sporting events. One officer who works in the elementary school learned each of the children’s birthdays, Ms. Hines said.

Advertise with us

“It’s a really really necessary,” Ms. Hines said. “We want to be part of that, we want to try to save lives on both sides of that. If the students and/or the police officers were to encounter one another after hours in the dark, we’re hoping that that relationship we’re building” would result in a peaceful resolution.

“I want that relationship built where there’s a peaceful resolution and nobody is injured and God forbid nobody is killed because we’ve learned to co-exist together.”

Megan Tomasic: mtomasic@post-gazette.com and Twitter: @MeganTomasic

__

Mental health strides

Advertise with us

Following Floyd’s murder and the ballooning of a novel pandemic, Black residents of Allegheny County knew what they needed, and they needed it quickly.

“Black folks were saying, ‘We need mental health treatment for ourselves, and we also want to learn how to support the mental health needs of folks in our community,’” said Julius Boatwright, CEO of the nonprofit Steel Smiling. The organization works as an intermediary between the community and medical professionals to connect them to services, and it is a byproduct of a collaboration with the group Neighborhood Allies.

Black residents were disproportionately affected both by severe COVID-19 disease and the blowback of Floyd’s murder, which sent shockwaves of protests rippling across the country. This spurred mental health discussions within Black communities in a new way, said Mr. Boatwright, chipping away at stigmas.

Since then, the nonprofit has launched peer support groups and collaborations with neighboring organizations like the Kingsley Association and Center for Life. Steel Smiling offers a 50-hour training for Black adults that teaches self care, community care and mental health first-aid. The group has also contracted with Black mental health providers in the region to reserve a certain number of sessions for Black individuals seeking mental health support. This helps complement existing medical care by supporting patients through feelings of trepidation with the health care system.

“If there are Black mental health supporters present, some Black folks might be more inclined to come to community centers,” said Mr. Boatwright. “At that point, we may be able to recommend further treatment options, like in-patient care. We build the bridge and walk over it with them instead of telling them to walk over it alone and figure it out.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Boatwright’s goal is for every Black resident to have at least one positive mental health experience by 2030, accomplished through strengthening Black mental health infrastructure and identifying community organizations they can support and collaborate with.

“The growth of the mental health model, specifically in Black communities, is really promising,” he said. “I think we are going to see a lot more investment into community-based mental health support.”

Hanna Webster: hwebster@post-gazette.com and Twitter: @hannamwebster

—

Beyond the whistle

Advertise with us

It was 2016 when NFL quarterback Colin Kaepernick sent shockwaves through the sports landscape with his on-field protests against police brutality. In the ensuing years, his choice to kneel during the national anthem and speak out against systemic racism loomed over football and other leagues, but in 2020, that movement was reignited by the George Floyd murder.

The Steelers found themselves in the spotlight, much like they did with a mishap during the national anthem in 2017 in Chicago. Before the 2020 season, the NFL announced that players would be permitted to apply messages to the back of their helmets, either a phrase promoting social justice or the name of a victim of police violence. Players across the league affixed a “George Floyd” decal to their helmet, but locally, the Steelers used that NFL initiative as a springboard to make a collective choice to honor Antwon Rose Jr., an East Pittsburgh 17-year-old fatally shot by a police officer in 2018 — or so they thought.

On national television, offensive lineman and Army veteran Alejandro Villanueva instead taped over “Antwon Rose” and wrote the name of Alwyn Cashe, a Black infantryman who was mortally wounded during active duty in Iraq in 2005. The starting left tackle and the organization at large had to address that internal division at a time when the sports world was largely uniting in the wake of Floyd’s killing.

Steelers players went their separate ways for the remainder of that season, choosing individual helmet messages like the other 31 teams. Three years later, the NFL continues to implement some of its post-Floyd ideas. “Lift Every Voice and Sing,” widely recognized as the Black national anthem, was played before the past three Super Bowls. When Chiefs and Eagles kicked off at SoFi Stadium in Los Angeles, one end zone read “End Racism” and the other “It Takes All Of Us.”

For his part and his former league, Mr. Kaepernick himself recently opined that the NFL hasn’t made any “substantial change” since his initial actions. Some would agree that the sports community had a fleeting moment of awareness before getting back to the ballgames, while others would argue 2020 was an inflection point in the ongoing story of athlete activism and playing outside-the-lines.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter: @BrianBatko

—

‘The world listened’

Monteze Freeland is a Baltimore native and Point Park University graduate who arrived in Pittsburgh in 2006 and never left. He has been working consistently in the Steel City’s theater world for the last 17 years as an actor, director, playwright, teaching artist and producer. About two years ago, he was named co-artistic director of the South Side-based City Theatre Company.

Like many Americans, Floyd’s murder left Mr. Freeland in a cloud of sadness and anger. It also inspired him to make sure those raw emotions weren’t only being felt by folks who look like him.

Advertise with us

“I wanted people to understand that this was a Black issue, but it’s also everyone’s issue,” said Mr. Freeland, who identifies as Black and queer. “And the world listened.”

On a personal level, the racial reckoning sparked by Floyd’s death prompted Mr. Freeland to “double down on the stories I like to tell” as a playwright. He’s currently working with the Asolo Repertory Theatre in Sarasota, Fla., on his latest play, “Dancing in the Blue Light,” which follows a group of Black, queer youth in 1960s Baltimore and explores what happens when a community experiencing constant violence takes matters into their own hands.

Prior to Floyd’s death, Mr. Freeland was serving as an associate producer at City Theatre. That changed in the aftermath of “We See You, White American Theater,” a manifesto released later that summer by a national collective of BIPOC theater-makers demanding that new practices be implemented “to address the scope and pervasiveness of anti-Blackness and racism in the American theater."

Those calls for increased attention to equity, diversity, inclusion and accessibility led to City Theatre adopting its own policy committing to those principles and bringing on both Mr. Freeland and Clare Drobot to serve as equals alongside previously established artistic director Marc Masterson.

Mr. Freeland believes that most Pittsburgh theaters are more diverse than they were prior to 2020 and are taking more deliberate approaches to their depictions of on-stage violence. That said, he wishes there was “a commitment to giving artists an equal experience” across the entire local theater scene.

Advertise with us

“It’s great that City Theatre can be a company trying hard every day to make those values and pillars a reality,” Freeland said. “But it doesn’t serve an artist if they go and get a gig at another company and that’s not the case.

“As organizations, we came together during the pandemic, and I want to see us coming together now to ask how we can further support the artistic community.”

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh