The search for Pittsburgh’s new police chief is over. But community leaders and stakeholders still have questions about how Mayor Ed Gainey made his decision. 

Larry Scirotto was officially nominated Wednesday to be the city’s next top cop, a year after former Chief Scott Schubert announced he was leaving to take a job with the FBI. 

Mr. Gainey hired the firm Public Sector Search & Consulting to assist in the search. But beyond that, much of the hiring process was conducted in secret. 

The city organized three panels to interview candidates — one made up of community members, one comprised of representatives from the police union, and one made up of the mayor’s executive team. 

Advertise with us

To give credibility to and “not undermine the integrity of the process,”  Beth Pittinger, the director of the Citizens Police Review Board, suggested that the Gainey administration disclose information about the panel’s meetings and who was involved. 

Community members were named publicly, but they and the police union members were asked to sign non-disclosure agreements regarding the process. Public Safety Director Lee Schmidt said the NDA’s were recommended by the city’s law department.

“Anytime we do a search, just like any other position in the city, it’s not really a public process as far as the interview with the panel,” he said Wednesday.

“I’m hesitant to say that it was a good, or a bad or an indifferent decision,” Ms. Pittinger said. “We’re more interested in the process of how that decision was arrived at. When we look at other jurisdictions, they’re very transparent about how they arrive at these kinds of decisions.” 

Earlier this year in Toledo, Ohio, Mayor Wade Kapszukiewicz released a list of 10 candidates — including names and current positions — that had been pulled from an initial 29 applications. Mr. Kapszukiewicz also invited community members to several public interviews.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh hasn’t released the names of other candidates or even how many applied and were interviewed. 

Mr. Scirotto spent 23 years with the Pittsburgh police until 2018. 

The Citizens Police Review Board can review anything related to police recruitment, hiring, training and other policies. It’s unclear if the board plans to probe the city’s decision to hire Mr. Scirotto. 

“Nobody’s wishing [Mr.] Scirotto ill will; you don’t want to see your chief of police fail,” Ms. Pittinger said. “But I think he’s coming in with some unnecessary challenges.”

Ms. Pittinger said it’s “unfortunate” that such an exciting day for someone who worked in the city for so long could be “tainted with the questions of process that are not of his own doing.”

Advertise with us

But questions about Mr. Scirotto’s hiring aren’t just about the process.

Mr. Scirotto served as the police chief in Fort Lauderdale, Fla., for less than a year before he was fired in 2022 amid allegations that he improperly favored non-white candidates in hiring decisions. Mr. Scirotto has defending his hiring practices.

Tim Stevens, the president and CEO of the Black Political Empowerment Project, said he’s not concerned about Mr. Scirotto’s history in Florida.

“The fact that he had issues in his former position in Fort Lauderdale because he was trying to advocate for diversity… I could certainly not be upset about that,” Mr. Stevens said. 

“I’m hopeful that he will be cognizant of… the policing attitudes across the country that are demanding reform and creating a positive balance between the community and the police,” Mr. Stevens added. “I do think he will have some sensitivity about these things.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Scirotto said Wednesday that, in Pittsburgh, “We will always prioritize diversity, but that does not mean we are sacrificing quality candidates.” 

Mr. Scirotto’s “executive leadership and maturity” stood out to Miracle Jones, who was on the panel of community members that evaluated candidates and currently serves as the Director of Policy and Advocacy at the arts and social justice nonprofit 1Hood Media. 

She also said Mr. Scirotto understands that “there are changes that need to be made and how to do it in a realistic, efficient way.”

Bob Swartzwelder, the president of the local police union, said that as long as the new chief “follows the working agreement,” there won’t be any issues. 

If confirmed by City Council, Mr. Scirotto will take over as the 55th chief in the bureau's 165-year history. A City Council member said Wednesday that there isn’t yet a timeline for when that will happen.