Lawyers questioned 81 prospective jurors, some for stretches of more than 40 minutes. Some of them wept. Others grew agitated by seemingly repetitive questions. Some were strongly in favor of executing the man who terrorized a Pittsburgh synagogue, while others called the death penalty morally wrong. A large number were somewhere in the middle.

And not a single juror was actually seated.

One week into jury selection for the trial of accused synagogue shooter Robert Bowers, little is known about what the eventual jury might look like. But the process has fallen into a steady if tedious rhythm.

The dozen or so people most involved in jury selection — Mr. Bowers, his four defense attorneys, four prosecutors, the judge, the U.S. Marshals, the court reporters — settled into a comfortable cadence over the course of the week.

Advertise with us

U.S. District Judge Robert Colville has used a personal, almost folksy tone during individual questioning.

“What I’d like to do with you here today is have a very casual, comfortable conversation,” he tells each juror, joking about how that’s surely difficult with the long line of lawyers, the microphones and the closed-circuit TV cameras.

The view from a prospective juror’s seat can indeed be intimidating. Each one sits at a small table with a microphone, the gallery and a closed-circuit camera behind them. Two long tables of attorneys and the judge sit in front of them.

The roughly half-dozen rows of benches in the courtroom’s galley have remained largely empty, save for occasional journalists and some of the victims’ family members. Some family members of the 11 people who died in the 2018 mass shooting have watched the proceedings from a live feed in a separate overflow room.

“It’s hard,” said Maggie Feinstein, director of the 10.27 Healing Project, which offers resources to people affected by trauma. “The families and victims are all reacting in very different ways.”

Advertise with us

The court needs to seat 12 jurors and at least six alternates to hear the case.

“What we’ve seen is that that’s really difficult in a case of capital murder,” Ms. Feinstein said. “There’s a lot of burden for the jurors to think deeply about how they feel about criminal justice, how they feel about the death penalty.”

Mr. Bowers, 50, is facing 63 federal charges stemming from the Oct. 27, 2018, shooting at a Squirrel Hill synagogue where three congregations worshipped: Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light.

Eleven worshippers were killed across those three congregations: Richard Gottfried, Joyce Fienberg, Rose Malinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax and Irving Younger.

Mr. Bowers remained fully engaged throughout the week, frequently taking notes and speaking with his attorneys. Seated toward the far end of the defense table, he often leaned forward to look at a potential juror as they spoke, or at a prosecutor speaking from the adjacent table.

Advertise with us

He’s not handcuffed while potential jurors are in the room — the sight of a defendant shackled could prejudice a future jury — but U.S. Marshals do handcuff him to lead him in and out of the courtroom during breaks. Mr. Bowers has dressed conservatively, sticking to a dark-colored sweater over a light-collared shirt.

Of those 81 potential jurors questioned in the first week — drawn from a pool of 1,500 residents from across the Pittsburgh region — about 27 are still eligible to be seated.

While plodding, the process is playing out as expeditiously as it feasibly can, said Bruce Antkowiak, a former federal prosecutor and defense attorney who teaches law at St. Vincent College.

The case’s high-profile nature can slow things down. In state and even federal courts, most prospective jurors usually aren’t familiar with the case at hand, he said, even if it is a death penalty case.

“In this case, you have to take the time and say, ‘OK, you read about the case — do you have any views about this matter?’” Mr. Antkowiak said. “And that’s even before you get into the questions about being able to impose the death penalty.”

Advertise with us

The jury selection process itself is also playing out in an unconventional manner.

In most cases, once a prospective juror is questioned, attorneys on either side can argue that a person shouldn’t be considered for the panel. Jurors can be excused for hardship or be “struck for cause” — in which one or both sides say a juror has shown he or she cannot be impartial.

Under typical circumstances, attorneys will make arguments for and against striking a juror for cause, and the presiding judge will quickly rule one way or another. Attorneys can then use, if they choose, what are known as peremptory strikes. These are used to dismiss a juror without giving a reason or showing cause. Each side has 20 such strikes in federal capital cases.

This case has been different.

While attorneys have made their arguments immediately following a potential juror’s questioning, Judge Colville has been granting or denying the strikes in batches the following morning. Peremptory strikes have yet to come into play, which means even the jurors who weren’t excluded in the first round of questioning might be later.

Advertise with us

Mr. Antkowiak said the purpose is to narrow down a pool of potential jurors from which all peremptory strikes will be exercised and, ultimately, the jury selected. The magic number for that smaller pool is probably 58: Twenty strikes for each side, leaving 12 jurors, and six alternates.

That can actually be helpful for the lawyers, Mr. Antkowiak said.

“You have your 20 strikes,” he said. “This person is now before you… and you’re saying to yourself, ‘If I take this strike, am I going to run out of strikes for some juror down the line I have not interviewed yet that I may think would be far worse of a juror?’”