A former Pittsburgh assistant police chief who was fired from his job leading a Florida police department for allegedly favoring non-white job candidates is poised to become the city’s next top cop, according to people familiar with the matter.
Larry Scirotto has been offered the job of Pittsburgh’s new police chief, said the people, who spoke on condition of anonymity because they weren’t authorized to discuss the matter. The department has been without a permanent head since former Chief Scott Schubert left last July.
Mr. Scirotto left the department in 2018 after 23 years. He had been promoted to assistant chief in 2016 under former Chief Cameron McLay. It was a newly created position in which he oversaw the Office of Professional Standards. The office is in charge of internal investigations, policy and training.
Prior to that, he was a commander in the major crimes unit.
Mr. Scirotto was known for his community-oriented approach to policing, often taking part in neighborhood events.
He was a finalist for the top job in Portland, Ore., in 2017. He retired from the Pittsburgh police a year later. In early 2021, he was also a finalist for police chief in San Jose, Calif.
Mr. Scirotto most recently led the police department in Fort Lauderdale, Fla. But he was fired less than a year into his tenure for allegedly favoring non-white candidates for promotions.
He still has an active lawsuit against the city of Fort Lauderdale. Filed in March in federal court in Florida, the suit seeks monetary damages and reinstatement to his former post or “to an equivalent position.” It also asks the court to reinstate his pension benefits.
Neither a city spokesperson nor Mr. Scirotto immediately commented Friday.
Mr. Scirotto was hired by Fort Lauderdale officials in June 2021 and took over the department two months later. By that November, city officials had hired a law firm to investigate complaints of discrimination, CNN reported in March 2022, days after Mr. Scirotto was fired.
A report from the law firm concluded that his approach to hiring and promotions unfairly focused on minority candidates. The report, which is included in Mr. Scirotto’s lawsuit against the city, alleged that he once pointed to a conference room wall bearing photos of the department’s command staff and said it was “too white” and “I’m gonna to change that.”
Mr. Scirotto told CNN that between when he started in August 2021 and November 2021, when the law firm was brought in, he promoted 15 people. He said six were, as CNN put it, ethnic or gender minorities.
“None of them were promoted because they were in a protected class,” he told the network. “They were promoted because they were the best candidates.”
“If promoting diversity is the hill I’m going to die on, I will sleep well tonight,” he added. “I won’t allow [the city] to tarnish my reputation. I won’t allow them to tarnish the work that I’ve done in the 24 years I’ve been in this profession.”
Chief Schubert announced his coming departure from the Pittsburgh department last May. The city contracted late last year with the firm Public Sector Search and & Consulting to bring in a pool of candidates. Mr. Scirotto’s lawsuit indicates that Fort Lauderdale used the same firm for the search that ultimately ended with his hire there.
At the time of Mr. Scirotto’s hiring, Fort Lauderdale leaders pointed to his 23-year record in Pittsburgh, where he reorganized the major crimes unit to prioritize crimes against people.
“We wanted someone who can shepherd this department into a new era of policing, build trust and keep the needs of our diverse community at the forefront,” city manager Chris Lagerbloom said then.
Mr. Scirotto was one of three finalists for Pittsburgh police chief. The other two were former Pittsburgh police commander Jason Lando, who currently leads a department in Maryland, and Ryan Lee, a former police chief in Boise, Idaho.
Chief Lando spent more than two decades with the Pittsburgh police, including time spent as commander of the city’s Zone 5 station, which oversees much of the East End, and of the Narcotics and Vice division. He was lauded for his work to improve police-community relations, praise that carried over to Maryland, too, with Frederick Mayor Michael O’Connor calling Chief Lando’s work outstanding last year.
Mr. Lee took over the Boise department in 2020 and came under scrutiny in October 2021 when he injured another officer during an impromptu demonstration of hold techniques at a staff meeting. No charges were filed, according to the Idaho Statesman.
Less than a month after prosecutors declined to file charges, KTVB reported that at least nine officers had filed complaints against Mr. Lee just in the spring of 2022. A day after the TV station aired the story, the mayor asked Mr. Lee to resign, according to the Spokesman-Review.
Acting Pittsburgh Police Chief Thomas Stangrecki has led the department on an interim basis since Chief Schubert’s departure. As the search for a permanent replacement dragged on and word of the finalists became public, Mayor Ed Gainey earlier this month praised all three of them.
“Each one of those candidates was above [an] A,” Mr. Gainey said. “They were great candidates. Each one of them were great candidates.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.