A discarded gas station coffee cup helped lead Allegheny County Police to two men they say dumped a body in a Scott Township alley last year.
Lavarr Carroll, 43, was found dead May 8 along Booth Way. Abdullah Faheem, 52, of Cincinnati, and Bradley Smith, 33, of Arnold, are charged with abuse of a corpse for their alleged roles in dumping him there.
An autopsy later showed Carroll died from a fentanyl overdose, police said.
Court records did not list a defense attorney for either man as of late Tuesday afternoon.
Carroll’s body was discovered around 8 a.m. in the alley and investigators said there was a liquid splattered on the ground nearby, according to the criminal complaints against Faheem and Smith. A plastic lid from a disposable coffee cup was near Carroll’s body, and a disposable GetGo coffee cup and a cup without a lid were found a short distance away.
Security cameras behind a nearby market captured the two men allegedly dumping Carroll’s body, police said. The video showed a dark-colored Cadillac pull into the alley and just out of camera view, according to the complaint. A man in a blue shirt with a white decal on the back can be seen leaving Carroll’s body in the alley around 4 a.m., police said.
Armed with the description of the car involved and with the coffee cup in mind, investigators checked security footage from the GetGo on Chestnut Street in Carnegie, according to the complaint. Around 2:30 a.m., Carroll is seen at the store, and two men later identified as Faheem and Smith arrived a short time later.
All three spend time at the store before Carroll gets into the car Smith and Faheem arrived in, police said. They leave and then come back, and the driver of the car — identified by police as Faheem — is seen trying to rouse an unresponsive Carroll, who is in the passenger seat. They leave the area shortly before 4 a.m., according to the complaint. Police said it is about a four-minute drive from the GetGo to the alley where Carroll was found.
Upon questioning, Faheem confirmed he had been with Smith that night and picked up Carroll, who he knew as “Hays,” according to the complaint. He said Carroll asked to be let out of the car near Plum Street and Washington Avenue, and Faheem then took Smith to the Hill District.
Smith, though, told investigators that Faheem dropped him off near Plum Street and then drove on with Carroll still in the car with him, according to the complaint.
A fingerprint from the discarded GetGo coffee cup found near Carroll’s body later came back as a match to Smith.
Both men were charged Monday with abuse of a corpse and conspiracy. Faheem was located Tuesday in an Ohio prison where he was serving time for a parole violation, police said. Investigators are still searching for Smith.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.