Donald Trump filed a $500 million lawsuit against his former lawyer Michael Cohen on Wednesday, alleging he violated attorney-client privilege in his evolution from loyal fixer to turncoat witness.
The lawsuit filed in federal court in Miami comes just a week after Mr. Trump was charged with 34 felonies related to checks issued to Cohen as reimbursement for a hush money payment to porn star Stormy Daniels ahead of the 2016 presidential election. Cohen, who went to federal prison for the payment, has cooperated heavily in the case and is expected to be the star witness at trial.
Mr. Trump’s suit lists five causes of action, accusing Cohen of committing an “onslaught of fiduciary and contractual breaches” in publishing two books, producing a podcast, and giving media interviews about paying off Daniels at Mr. Trump’s behest.
Cohen’s “wrongful actions were intentional, calculated, malicious, and motivated by his desire to acquire fame, attention, notoriety, and wealth,” alleges the lawsuit.
The suit doubles down on Mr. Trump’s claim he was innocent of wrongdoing in the hush money deal because he relied on Cohen’s legal advice and that Cohen made the illicit payment out of a personal desire “to protect his family from the malicious and false claims” by Daniels.
It accuses Cohen of profiting off Mr. Trump’s woes and details how Cohen went from Mr. Trump’s biggest fan in high school to a central figure in the criminal case brought by Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg.
“Among other innumerable positive statements made by [Cohen] about [Mr. Trump] and his role as [Mr. Trump’s] attorney, [Cohen] described his job as ‘very surreal,’ claiming he had ‘been admiring Donald Trump since ... high school,’” reads an excerpt of the lawsuit.
“[Cohen] viewed [Mr. Trump] as a ‘wonderful man’ who would be ‘an amazing president,’ and someone [Cohen] thought ‘the world’ of as ‘a businessman’ and ‘a boss.’”
Cohen pleaded guilty to campaign violations and other crimes in August 2018, with him and the feds directly implicating then-President Trump in the hush money case, where he’s referred to as “Individual 1.” Cohen started talking to state investigators, who were separately probing the deal, from prison and continued cooperating when he was released to home confinement at his Trump Park Ave family residence.
The case, while potentially far-fetched, suggests that Mr. Trump may be seeking to silence Cohen.
“It could be an attempt to pressure Michael Cohen not to testify, but that pressure is unlikely to work,” said Ellen Yaroshefsky, a professor specializing in legal ethics at Hofstra University’s law school.
She added that she did not think the lawsuit amounted to witness tampering under New York law, as it was not a direct attempt to interfere with Cohen’s testimony, and other legal experts concurred.
Yet in a statement Wednesday, Cohen’s lawyer, Lanny Davis brushed off the lawsuit as frivolous and said Mr. Trump was trying to scare off other people from cooperating against him.
“Mr. Trump appears once again to be using and abusing the judicial system as a form of harassment and intimidation against Michael Cohen. It appears he is terrified by his looming legal perils and is attempting to send a message to other potential witnesses who are cooperating with prosecutors against him,” Mr. Davis said.
“Mr. Cohen will not be deterred and is confident that the suit will fail based on the facts and the law.”
An attorney representing Mr. Trump in the matter, Alejandro Brito, did not immediately return a request seeking comment.
Mr. Trump has been eager to file the suit for some time, according to a person familiar with his thinking, even as some members of his legal team have discouraged him from doing so.
Stephen Gillers, a professor emeritus at the New York University School of Law who specializes in legal ethics, said that he saw no problems with the appropriateness of the lawsuit on its face.
“The theory of the lawsuit is that Cohen, as Trump’s former lawyer, had fiduciary and professional obligations to Trump that he breached and caused damage to Trump,” Mr. Gillers said. “That theory, without the names of the parties, is quite plausible.”
But he added that while lawyers could not ordinarily do what the lawsuit said Cohen had done in speaking about a former client, Cohen would have had certain rights to defend himself when he became a target of a criminal investigation.
Like Ms. Yaroshefsky, Mr. Gillers did not think that the suit amounted to witness tampering, nor did Bruce Green, a law professor at Fordham University.
The New York Times contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.