Zachary Dinell admitted to the graphic abuse he inflicted for almost a year upon the severely disabled who were under his care at McGuire Memorial in Beaver County, but the pain and anguish — the nightmares and the trauma — will last a life time, family members of his victims told Dinell in federal court Thursday.

In an emotional sentencing hearing, U.S. District Judge J. Nicholas Ranjan listened as those who sent their loved ones to the Daugherty facility to receive the care they needed spoke about how Dinell’s abuse — compounded by the vile videos he recorded and the braggart text messages he exchanged with a coworker — has changed them.

“I can only imagine the emotions my son felt when [Dinell] punched and tortured him,” Karen Pennell said of her son, Connor, a McGuire resident. “Nobody had ever hurt him before.”

Dinell, 29, was indicted in federal court in early 2022 alongside former coworker Tyler Smith on federal hate crime charges based on their alleged violent and degrading abuse of the residents in their care at McGuire Memorial, a facility that largely cares for children and adults with severe disabilities, many of whom are nonverbal and some who cannot even move.

Advertise with us

A status hearing for Smith is scheduled for next month.

A plea deal struck in October stipulated that Dinell would be sentenced in the range of 14 to 17 years. The federal case brought hate crime charges, alleging Dinell and Smith carried out the abuse because of their hatred of the disabled residents.

Ms. Pennell said she worries about the nightmares her son might have or how scared he might be when someone comes near him who looks like Dinell or sounds like Dinell or even smells like him. Connor, too, is nonverbal.

“He can’t tell me how much it hurt,” Ms. Pennell said. “That’s what they counted on.”

She pointed to one text message in which Dinell wrote to Smith that they look at the residents “as less than people.”

Advertise with us

“We all know who is ‘less than people’ in this room,” she said.

Indeed, the indictment against Dinell and Smith details their disregard for their patients’ pain and suffering at their hands.

In several videos recorded in March 2017, Dinnell recorded himself throwing a clear substance in one resident’s face while the resident was naked in a bathroom. Dinell texted Smith, according to the charges against them, that he “got some good things to show you.”

They called it “sanitizing” the residents, according to the indictment.

Earlier that year, in reference to the same patient, Dinell wrote to Smith: “He didn’t ask to be born that way. But here we are sanitizing his eyes and beating him.”

Advertise with us

Ryan Smith, Dinell’s public defender, called his client a withdrawn young man who struggled with anxiety and had trouble making eye contact.

“It is difficult for him to face even himself for what he did let along face [victims’ family members],” Mr. Smith said.

He said Dinell was drinking heavily while employed at McGuire as a caretaker to cope with his anxiety. He said Dinell’s lack of previous criminal record showed the abuse was an “aberration” and said there was a “good chance it won’t happen again.”

Heather Harold spoke of her baby brother, Nicholas, who was exactly six and a half years younger than her. She said she was enthralled with him when he was born and got into more than one playground brawl defending him.

“They were at [Dinell’s] mercy,” she said, “and he had none.”

Advertise with us

Their mother, Catherine Wickline, too, spoke of Nicholas, who died at age 39 in October 2017. He couldn’t roll over, she said, or even lift his hands.

Both pleaded for the judge to sentence him to the maximum 17 years allowed by the plea agreement Dinell entered into when he changed his plea to guilty in October.

Dinell, for his part, told the judge he takes full responsibility for his actions.

“It was terrible. It was awful,” he said, wearing black-framed glasses and a neon orange federal inmate jumpsuit. “I will never forgive myself.”

His remorse came with a “but,” however, as he told the judge and the victims’ family members that “there was not a sexual element to it.” He said he thought the family members should know that.

Advertise with us

“I’m really, really sorry,” he said. “I just wish I could take it back.”

Judge Ranjan ultimately took heed of the families’ pleas, sentencing Dinell to 17 years in prison. He told Dinell that he believed his remorse was sincere but noted it came too little too late.

“I’m struck by the fact this wasn’t a one-time occurrence. There were many points in time remorse could have been had and changes made,” he said. “The time for remorse has long passed.”