Prosecutors on Monday dropped a homicide charge against two men accused in an October shootout on the North Side that ultimately killed three people.
Based on trajectory information they received after charges were filed, prosecutors said, any shots fired by either Samuel Peagues or Charron Troutman could not have been the shots that killed 20-year-old John Hornezes.
Peagues, 30, and Troutman, 19, were both charged for their alleged roles in the Oct. 15 shootout on Cedar Avenue near the Sunoco gas station. Three people were killed in the gun fight: Jacquelyn Mehalic, 33, and Betty Jean Averytt, 59, were both at a bus stop near the corner of Cedar and Pressley Street when they were caught in the gunfire. Hornezes, who police have said was likely among the shooters, was found dead in the park across Cedar Avenue from the gas station and bus stop.
Jaylone Hines, 22, is charged in connection with the women’s deaths.
Peagues and Troutman had been charged specifically in the death of Hornezes. Prosecutors withdrew the homicide charge against each of them ahead of a preliminary hearing Friday morning.
The hearing was moved from Pittsburgh Municipal Court on First Avenue to the Court of Common Pleas and included stepped-up security. No cellphones were permitted inside the third-floor courtroom, and more than a half-dozen sheriff’s deputies stood watch inside.
Read More
The increased security likely stems from the aftermath of Hornezes’ death: Two people allegedly opened fire on the North Side church where Hornezes’ funeral was being held two weeks later. Five people were injured by gunfire. Two suspects — Shawn Davis, 19, and Hezekiah Nixon, 16 — are set for preliminary hearings early next month.
The prosecutors’ cases against Peagues and Troutman relied mostly on video evidence collected from that section of Cedar Avenue.
Taken all together, prosecutors said, the footage showed Peagues driving his mother’s black Hyundai Tucson with Troutman in the passenger seat at the Sunoco shortly after 10 p.m. the night of the shooting. Across the street, several others — including, allegedly, Hornezes and Hines — emerge from the park.
Footage shows the Hyundai pulling out of the gas station and making a right onto Pressley Street, all while muzzle flashes from gunfire can be seen inside, prosecutors said. Muzzle flashes show gunfire coming from the park toward the Tucson as well.
Pittsburgh police detectives identified Peagues and Troutman as the men captured by surveillance cameras in the area.
Though prosecutors withdrew the homicide charges against both men, they added two counts of attempted homicide, one count of aggravated assault and five counts of reckless endangerment for both men.
Brandon Herring, defense attorney for Peagues, argued the occupants of the SUV were trying to get away from the gunfire.
“They were going about their business until they look over into this park and see several individuals squared up and ready to fight,” he said.
He said no one could even prove Peagues had fired a gun.
Troutman’s defense attorney, Elbert Gray Jr., did not offer a closing argument for his client.
District Judge Michele Santicola ordered both men to stand trial. Formal arraignments are scheduled for late February.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.