A judge on Wednesday dismissed all charges against a teenager accused in a shooting at Kennywood during the opening weekend of the park’s Halloween season, agreeing with the defense attorney’s argument that evidence showed only that the boy was a victim, not a shooter.

The charges against 15-year-old Darryl Pirl were dismissed after a two-hour preliminary hearing in front of District Judge James J. Hanley Jr.

Family members in the courtroom broke into applause upon Judge Hanley’s ruling.

Mr. Pirl’s attorney, Kenneth Haber, called the case presented by prosecutors “smoke and mirrors,” arguing prosecutors presented circumstantial evidence that did nothing more than prove Mr. Pirl was a gunshot victim at Kennywood that night.

Advertise with us

“(Mr. Pirl) is a victim of the juvenile justice system gone awry,” he said.

He hinted that public outrage over the Sept. 24 shooting at the popular amusement park might have pushed police and prosecutors to move forward with the case.

“To file charges based on evidence this thin, I think, suggests that there was a lot of pressure on the police, on the prosecution,” Mr. Haber said outside the courtroom at Pittsburgh Municipal Court. “I’m not suggesting they didn’t do everything they could to solve the case, but I am stating that they didn’t have evidence that my client committed this offense.”

The shooting at Kennywood’s Phantom Fall Fest wounded three people, including Mr. Pirl. He came onto police radar when an Allegheny County Police detective interviewed him at UPMC McKeesport, where a relative drove him some time after the shooting.

Detectives said holes in Mr. Pirl’s black T-shirt appeared to be from gunshots but noted that they could not have been caused by the same bullets that struck Mr. Pirl’s leg. Beyond that, Detective Nicole DePaoli testified, the holes appeared to have been made by bullets being fired from underneath the shirt.

Advertise with us

She also said tests showed gunshot residue on his hands and on the inside and outside of his shirt and hoodie indicated the same. Mr. Haber argued the gunshot residue showed only that Mr. Pirl was very near a gun when it was fired.

Brandon Ward was among those shot and wounded that night. He testified that he was standing at the Music Express with his fiancé as his 10-year-old daughter and her friend waited in line for the ride.

Mr. Ward, who still walks with a limp and sometimes uses a cane, said he saw three teenage boys approaching from his left wearing gaiter-type masks and sweatshirts with the hoods up. Two of the teens, he said, kept walking while another hung back.

“I turned to my fiancé and said, ‘I think something’s about the pop off,’” he testified.

Immediately after, he said, someone pushed into the back of them and he heard a shot. He said he immediately knew he’d been hit in the leg.

Advertise with us

Another teenager was shot, as was Mr. Pirl.

One detective testified that she initially interviewed Mr. Pirl as a victim. He told her he’d been at the park and heard gunshots, at which point an employee laid on top of him in an effort to protect him from gunfire. The employee, Ms. DePaoli said, corroborated that.

One gun was recovered in the aftermath of the shooting — a 9mm Glock found a short distance from the Music Express, another detective testified. Mr. Haber noted it would be difficult for Mr. Pirl to discard the gun some distance away while he was on the ground with the employee who attempted to shield him.

Detective Todd Wateska testified that they had no fingerprint or DNA evidence that linked Mr. Pirl to the gun. He also said security footage showed Mr. Pirl entering the park properly through the front entrance, where he went through the weapons detection system the park uses as a security measure.

The prosecution noted, however, that there are areas around the perimeter of the park where people can sneak in, and some spaces in the fencing are large enough that something like a firearm could be passed through.

“(Prosecutors) have nothing but a theory, and theories are not evidence,” Mr. Haber said.