Lawyers representing a former West Mifflin Area High School football player on Thursday opened their case against his former school and athletic leagues by claiming their failures led to his concussion and subsequent symptoms, while defense attorneys sought to position the sports agencies as volunteer organizations that don’t have the resources to monitor every player in the league.

Shane Skillpa, a former student-athlete who says his 2009 concussion during a football practice has led to years of debilitating mental health symptoms, sued the West Mifflin Area School District in 2017 alleging the conditions and harsh drills at football practices led to his head injury. He and his attorneys say the WPIAL and its parent organization, the statewide PIAA, are also responsible.

Attorney Richard Sanow, who represents Mr. Skillpa, told the Allegheny Common Pleas jury that there were three things that caused his client’s injury to be so severe.

One factor was the “Oklahoma-style” drills the football team ran, which Mr. Sanow said increased the chances of helmet-to-helmet contact. Mr. Skillpa has said that he collided hard enough with the other player during the drill that his helmet broke.

Advertise with us

The second factor Mr. Sanow listed was the West Mifflin school’s decision to remove a cushion underneath its field when it replaced the turf in 2009.

What may have been the most important factor, Mr. Sanow said, was that Mr. Skillpa was not removed from practice after his head injury; he was told to get a new helmet and return to practice after a brief rest.

This decision meant he was not cleared by a medical professional to continue practice, leading to second-impact syndrome, Mr. Sanow said, causing the injury to become more serious.

Now, Mr. Skillpa relies on “strong” psychiatric medications to deal with his myriad symptoms, such as short-term memory loss, Mr. Sanow told the jury.

But defense attorneys said Mr. Skillpa’a long-term symptoms, which include anxiety and depression, existed before his head injury and are unrelated to the concussion. Attorney Andrew Kimball told the jury that their experts would prove that his concussion symptoms would have subsided in the 13 years since the incident.

Advertise with us

Many questions will arise during this trial, Mr. Kimball said to the jury, and “you will have to decide whether this is a result of a concussion or if this is just who Shane is.”

Mr. Kimball said millions of people experience symptoms such as attention deficit disorder and social anxiety without having had a concussion, and he cited Mr. Skillpa’s decision to enter therapy in the seventh grade as an example of when Mr. Skillpa described feelings of fatigue and memory problems before he experienced his concussion.

“Shane is normal,” Mr. Kimball said. “His symptoms can be explained without reference to concussion.”

He repeatedly framed the PIAA as a “charitable, nonprofit organization” that doesn’t have the resources to observe every practice at its 1,450 member schools.

“All of that is handled by a very small staff of 20 people,” he said.

Advertise with us

The responsibility, Mr. Kimball said, fell on Mr. Skillpa to tell the school’s athletic staff and his parents that he felt unwell. Mr. Skillpa maintains that he told coaches he was seeing stars, had a headache and felt dazed after he was hit.

The PIAA was already making efforts to reduce concussions by encouraging proper training and conditioning, equipment and techniques, such as reducing helmet-to-helmet contact, Mr. Kimball said.

“You can do all you can to protect student athletes,” Mr. Kimball said, “but you cannot prevent concussions altogether.”

Mr. Skillpa, now 29, testified that he was told by a coach that he had his “bell rung” after the injury, despite claiming that he told the coach that he was seeing stars.

“He told me my bell was rung,” Mr. Skillpa repeated. “That’s the term he gave it. It was normalized.”

Advertise with us

Three days passed before Mr. Skillpa addressed his symptoms, which had grown to include a low fever, to his mother.

He said he believes he completed his undergraduate education in information technology with the help of medication that helped him focus and alleviate his anxiety, but he felt it would be impractical to pursue a career in that field because he is unable to look at screens for long periods, so he became a registered nurse.

Now, he relies on detailed, hour-by-hour notes to complete his tasks at work because his short-term memory suffers, he said.

“If I lose my clipboard, I’m scrambling to find it,” Mr. Skillpa said.

His worsening memory, he said, was one of the major symptoms that began to cause concern for him and his family. In one incident, he left a car running in the garage without realizing it. Another time he left the house with food still in the oven, causing the fire alarm to go off. One evening, he left the garage door open, allowing his family’s dogs to escape their home.

Advertise with us

“I was in my 20s,” he testified. “I didn’t know anyone else my age who did, for lack of a better term, stupid things like that.”

During cross-examination, defense attorneys again questioned Mr. Skillpa’s mental health history prior to the concussion, including an ImPACT Baseline Test he took to measure effects of a potential concussion prior to beginning high school football.

On the test, which asks for answers on a 0-6 scale (the highest number represented the most intense feeling), he answered that he was at a “2” for fatigue, a “1” for sensitivity to light, “5” for sadness, “3” for nervousness and “5” for feeling emotional.

But Mr. Skillpa said he mistakenly believed that he was answering on a 0-10 scale. “This was unsupervised,” he said. “At that moment, on that day, I could have had a bad day.”

He also said that coaches didn’t emphasize the importance that the test played in determining what a player’s baseline emotional state was prior to a concussion.

Advertise with us

Mr. Skillpa’s mother, Jennifer Recktosh, was called to the stand to describe when she first noticed her son’s symptoms. She testified that he was “perfectly” fine prior to the concussion, with no health conditions or medications.

The only exception was a single therapy session after abruptly changing school districts in seventh grade, she said.

“He was fine,” she testified. “He was happy, he had a lot of friends.”

But after his head injury in August 2009, he began exhibiting symptoms such as motion sickness and trouble with his balance. During an examination, a specialist observed signs of concussion when his eyes began to shake after he was asked to look in different directions.

“What was your reaction to that?” Mr. Sanow asked.

Advertise with us

“I cried,” she said.

By 2016, his symptoms worsened to include memory issues, anxiety, mood swings and depressions.

But defense attorney Lauren Kelly, cross examining Ms. Recktosh, honed in on questions about her family’s mental health history, saying Mr. Skillpa reported to his doctors that multiple members of his family experienced depression.

Joe Lavara, the attorney representing West Mifflin Area School District, focused on differences between Ms. Recktosh’s testimony and her pre-trial deposition.

In her deposition, she told attorneys that a coach asked her son if he was OK following the 2009 head injury, to which Mr. Skillpa responded that he was fine. But she later recanted that statement.

Advertise with us

“Shane never did tell me that the coach asked if he was OK,” she said later, according to the transcript shown in the courtroom.

But she also recanted that statement, finally saying Thursday that she had a conversation with her son prior to the trial where he confirmed that he had spoken to a coach after the concussion had taken place.

The trial continues Friday and is expected to take two weeks.

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com