The mother of a Central Catholic student fatally shot at a North Versailles Halloween hayride has sued the venue over the killing, which remains unsolved nearly a year later.
Robert Peirce and Associates, acting on behalf of Shantel Pizaro, on Friday announced the wrongful death lawsuit against Haunted Hills Hayride. Ms. Pizaro’s 15-year-old son, Steven Eason Jr. of Wilmerding, was killed while attending the attraction.
Steven was killed while trying to break up a fight that had begun while waiting for the hayride. The person who instigated the fight fired three shots, fatally striking Steven in the stomach and chest. Another teen was injured by the other shot. The shooter has not been publicly identified or charged by police.
Ms. Pizaro, in a civil complaint filed Friday in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, claims the hayride’s lack of security contributed to her son’s death on Sept. 11, 2021.

Her complaint says there were no metal detectors or security checks when entering the hayride, which is operated by defendant BB Production Company, Inc. But after a two-week closure following Steven’s death, the Haunted Hills Hayride reopened with hired security guards and did bag checks and searches for weapons. It also instituted a policy that attendees under 16 years old needed an adult present to enter the site.
Those policies remain in place as the hayride plans to begin its 23rd season later this month, according to the attraction’s website.
“The Haunted Hills Hayride owed Steven Eason Jr. a duty of reasonable care to prevent individuals from entering the facility with weapons, including firearms,” the suit reads. “The Haunted Hills Hayride violated that duty in failing to have proper security measures in place to protect its patrons, including Steven Eason Jr.”
The suit alleges two counts of negligence, demands a jury trial and is asking for compensatory damages.
A phone number listed for Haunted Hills Hayride was disconnected, and the company could not be reached for comment Friday.
Attorney Robert Peirce III said the intention of the suit is to learn more about what happened to Steven, to raise publicity about the incident and others like it and to “put businesses on notice” that simple security measures can protect people from harm.
“It is our belief that had these simple procedures been put in place prior to Sept. 11, 2021, Steven would not have passed away,” said Mr. Peirce at a press conference Friday morning. “This family would not be dealing with what they’ve had to deal with over the past year.”
Mr. Peirce said they intend to learn everything they can about how the shooting took place and how it could have been prevented, including working with local authorities and sharing information with them.
Responding to questions about the status of the criminal investigation into Steven’s killing, Allegheny County Police Sgt. Todd Dolfi said, “This case remains an open and active investigation. We have no further information to release at this time.”
The hayride did not have security cameras on site, Mr. Peirce said. But police have asked those who had cellphone footage of the fight to come forward to help with the criminal investigation.
Mr. Peirce said his office intends to request and obtain access to that data and other evidence connected to the shooting within the next three to four months.
“I’m very proud of him,” Ms. Pizaro said of her son’s attempts to break up the fight. “But as every parent [knows,] you’re human. Sometimes I wish he didn’t, because maybe my son would still be here.”
The shooting resulted in disruptions to local high school football teams in the weeks following the incident. A game between Woodland Hills and Penn Hills high schools was held without fans, with the schools citing “unresolved feelings and emotions” surrounding the killing as the rationale. A Leechburg and Clairton football game also went forward without fans for similar reasons.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.