Gateway High School’s band director has been accused of providing alcohol to an 18-year-old student on multiple occasions in the past year.

And while police only charged James Hoeltje, 37, of Plum, with giving alcohol to a minor, court paperwork also suggests that he was “grooming” the student and had sexually assaulted her — a claim he denies.

According to a Monroeville police affidavit that accompanied the charges filed on Monday, the student told police that she had known Mr. Hoeltje since she was in fifth grade and first gave her his phone number in the summer of 2021 before her senior year.

The student, who graduated in the spring, said the two started exchanging messages in January, mostly over the Snapchat app.

Advertise with us

Whether it was on Snapchat, via text message or in person, the student said conversations between her and Mr. Hoeltje were sometimes sexual in nature, including instances of the band director telling her about his sex life with his wife, according to the complaint.

She said Mr. Hoeltje would often hold her hand or hug her while they were alone in his office, and the hugs sometimes lasted a minute or two.

On a band trip to Virginia Beach, Va., at the end of April, the student said Mr. Hoeltje gave her travel-sized bottles of vodka and whiskey while they were in his hotel room. She said she drank the alcohol then became dizzy and laid on the bed.

According to the complaint, Mr. Hoeltje then climbed on top of her and attempted to kiss her, but she was able to squirm out from under him. As she left the room, the complaint said, he grabbed her buttocks and told her to come back later.

On May, 12, the day before Gateway’s prom, the student said Mr. Hoeltje placed a bottle of Tito’s Vodka in a brown bag inside her bookbag during school hours. The student said she took the bottle home after prom and shared it with two other students, one of whom became sick and vomited after drinking it, according to the complaint.

Advertise with us

Police said they found a text message on the student’s phone that Mr. Hoeltje sent her on prom night that read, “Goofy semi-drunk snaps are also highly encouraged and appreciated to cheer me up!!”

Mr. Hoeltje admitted to giving the student alcohol but denied the sexual assault.

He told investigators that when he and the student were in Virginia Beach, she took a mini bottle of alcohol and he did not attempt to stop her. He said he may have accidentally touched her buttocks when she was leaving the room as he was reaching for the door handle, but he said he did not try to kiss her.

The band director acknowledged that he had hugged the student on multiple occasions and had probably shared too much information about his personal life with her, according to the complaint. He also said that he gave the student the bottle of vodka for the school prom at her request.

Mr. Hoeltje could not immediately be reached for comment. An attorney was not listed.

Advertise with us

A preliminary hearing was scheduled for Oct. 3.

The criminal complaint does not explain why Mr. Hoeltje was not charged in the alleged sexual assault, and it was not clear if further charges were possible.

When reached Monday, Monroeville police Chief Doug Cole would not comment on the case.

Mr. Hoeltje been the band director since 2016, according to the Gateway band website.

In a letter to district parents and guardians on Monday, Gateway Superintendent William Short said he was contacted by the Monroeville police regarding an investigation into a school employee on Friday. He said the employee was immediately placed on leave.

Advertise with us

Mr. Short noted that marching band camp, which was slated to start Monday, would have to be postponed. He did not indicate when camp may resume.

“The Monroeville police will continue their investigation and communicate findings to my office,” Mr. Short said. “Upon confirmation, I will update our staff, families, and constituents. In closing, I ask for everyone’s patience and understanding while we work with the police to resolve the situation a resume marching band camp.”

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com.