One of the last times Sarah Grubbs saw her uncle was at his 60th birthday party. Hosted at his Oakmont home last summer, the event was complete with a taco truck, plenty of friends and family, and “merriment” all around.

July 28 is Marc Fogel’s 61st birthday, but there’s not much to celebrate.

The long-time international educator has been detained in Russia for 11 months following his arrest at the Sheremetyevo airport in Moscow in August for possession of about 20 grams of medical marijuana.

Fogel was en route to the Anglo-American School in Moscow, where he had taught high school history for close to a decade. He planned to retire the following year and return to Oakmont.

Advertise with us

In June, he was found guilty of “large-scale drugs smuggling” and sentenced to 14 years in a high-security penal colony.

Russia’s Interior Ministry has said that Fogel could have used his diplomatic status as a way to smuggle drugs into the country; his family has disputed the claim and said his sentence is overly harsh and likely politically motivated.

“For him, that’s almost a death sentence,” said Ms. Grubbs, a lifelong Butler resident.

Her uncle has struggled with chronic pain for a long time and has had multiple surgeries, including three back surgeries, a spinal fusion, a hip replacement and two knee surgeries, she said.

“He wasn’t smuggling marijuana with the intent to distribute it,” said Ms. Grubbs. “He just wanted to control chronic pain so he can continue doing what he loves.”

Advertise with us

Fogel’s family and friends have drawn parallels between his case and those of WNBA basketball star Brittney Griner and police officer Paul Whelan. The U.S. State Department has classified both Ms. Griner and Whelan as having been “wrongfully detained,” a designation that allows their cases to be handled by the Office of the Special Presidential Envoy for Hostage Affairs.

The Biden administration offered to exchange Viktor Bout, a Russian arms trafficker, for Ms. Griner and Whelan Thursday. No agreement has been reached yet, a Kremlin spokesperson said Thursday.

The State Department has not classified Fogel as having been “wrongfully detained,” excluding him from consideration in hostage negotiations.

“It is crushing that they wouldn’t try to bring them all home,” said Ben Johnson, a California resident who is one of Fogel’s former students. “Now we are negotiating for hostages, so why selectively? What is it about adding Marc to that list that is prohibitive?”

In response to a request for comment, the State Department referred to comments made during a press briefing Tuesday. A spokesperson said the department is aware of Fogel’s case and is “monitoring the situation,” but did not elaborate on why he has not been granted wrongful detention status, citing privacy considerations.

Advertise with us

Before the sentencing, Ms. Grubbs and other family members kept quiet, hoping Fogel’s lack of criminal record and the relatively small amount of marijuana he had on hand would result in a merciful sentence. “Everyone was advised to keep a low profile and let the due process take its course,” she said.

But when the magnitude of the sentence sunk in, they decided to take more direct action. One friend started a Facebook group called “Friends of Marc Fogel” to coordinate a letter-writing campaign, particularly targeting Secretary of State Antony Blinken. Kelly Leguineche, another of Fogel’s nieces, started a Change.org petition which has amassed nearly 2,000 signatures.

Mr. Johnson said he has been “shotgunning” letters and has written three rounds so far. The prospect of his long-time role model spending a dozen years in prison is “unfathomable,” he said. “He’s going to die in a labor camp if they don’t take this seriously.”

“We just want to do anything we can in our power to bring him home where we know he belongs,” said Ms. Grubbs.

A citizen of the world with Pittsburgh roots

Advertise with us

Fogel always had an adventurous spirit, his family and friends say. Though he started his teaching career domestically, at Winchester-Thurston in Pittsburgh and in Washington, his desire to see the world eventually drove him to teach high school history internationally.

Alongside his wife, Jane, Fogel taught across the globe for 35 years, including in Malaysia, Mexico, Colombia, Oman and Venezuela.

But in every corner of the world, the Butler native never forgot his Steel City roots.

While teaching at the International School of Kuala Lumpur in Malaysia in the early 1990s, Fogel used to pore over the sports page of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, which he would have mailed to him.

“He loved his Pirates, his Steelers, his Penguins,” said Mike Larios, a former colleague of Fogel’s in Malaysia. “He was constantly talking about his Pittsburgh days.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Johnson, one of Fogel’s students at the time, said the two bonded over their shared Pittsburgh heritage — Mr. Johnson had spent much of his childhood in Moon before moving to Malaysia when his stepfather took a job abroad.

During breaks between classes, Mr. Johnson would stop by Fogel’s classroom, a ritual that became a reprieve from his homesickness.

“We’d talk about sports and talk about home and put on really funny Pittsburgh accents,” he said. “He really did save me. For someone to take that kind of interest in a kid is special.”

Mr. Larios, a physical education teacher at the school, often played pickup basketball with Fogel in the mornings. He said Fogel had a charismatic, magnetic personality and was a dynamic presence in the classroom. “Kids loved him. Absolutely loved him,” he said. “When he talked about history, it was a story. And who doesn’t love to be read stories and told stories?”

Kamakshi Balasubramanian, who taught with Fogel in Muscat, Oman, in the early 2000s and now lives in India, praised his commitment to instilling good values in his students. “His lively teaching method has been fundamental to developing human beings who understand what human rights are,” she said.

Advertise with us

In Muscat, Fogel founded his school’s first Model United Nations program. He also led students on an annual field trip to Vietnam to study the legacy of the Vietnam War.

Fatima Zaidi was one of Fogel’s students in Muscat, and credits him with sparking her interest in history, which she eventually studied as a minor in college.

“A great teacher can have such a profound and formative impact on your long-term sense of self-worth. And that’s what he instilled in me,” she said.

Mr. Johnson kept in touch with Fogel well past graduation. The two had planned to finally watch a Pirates game together, but had never been in Pittsburgh at the same time.

He last heard from his former teacher in June 2021, when he texted Fogel a picture of his young son atop Mount Washington, with a panoramic view of Pittsburgh’s skyline in the background.

Advertise with us

Fogel complimented the picture and texted back: “The plan is the retirement gig after next year. Carpe diem!” Mr. Johnson hasn’t heard from him since.

A mismatched sentence

In addition to his infectious energy, many of Fogel’s former students recall his funny walk: pitched a little forward, with his back arched.

The teacher had lived with chronic pain for decades, and received back surgery starting in his 30s.

He had been prescribed medical marijuana as a “safer alternative” to opioids, which he was opposed to taking, said Ms. Grubbs. The cannabis was packaged in a contact lens container, as well as in e-cigarette cartridges, according to the Russian Interior Ministry.

Advertise with us

The roughly half an ounce of cannabis that caused his detainment was likely his “personal supply to get him through the year,” said Mr. Johnson. It is unclear whether Fogel had brought medical marijuana to Moscow in years prior.

When Mr. Johnson first heard about the arrest through a chat room with former high school classmates, his first reaction was: “‘What were you thinking?’” But his reaction quickly turned more forgiving. “But then I think about it and it’s like, ‘You know what? When I was younger, I traveled with marijuana products. I did stupid stuff,’” he said.

“It’s obviously breaking the law. It’s not a death sentence. Fourteen years of hard labor does not match the crime that was committed,” he said.

Mr. Larios was “heartbroken” when he found out about Fogel’s arrest, a feeling that only worsened when Russia declared war on Ukraine. “When the war started it was like, ‘Oh my God.’ From bad to worse.”

The sentence Fogel received was “ridiculously, way harsher than anything he did,” said Mr. Larios.

Advertise with us

Since last August, Fogel’s family has only been able to communicate with him via letters, an imperfect communication channel at best, subject to translation errors and, the family fears, censorship.

In the meantime, all family and friends can do is try to put pressure on the State Department and hope.

If Ms. Grubbs were able to talk to her uncle directly, she said she would assure him “that he is not forgotten about. We’re trying everything. And I know that at times, it may feel hopeless, but he’s one of the most optimistic people that I know.

“I want him to know that he needs to keep fighting because we want to bring him home.”

Maliya Ellis: mellis@post-gazette.com.