When private citizens complained in court about Pittsburgh’s assault weapons ban in the wake of the Tree of Life shooting, they were dismissed by District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala in a decision supported by a judge.

An appeals court now has reversed that decision.

A ruling handed down from the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court on Tuesday says that Mr. Zappala should have accepted the citizens’ complaint.

Mr. Zappala refused to hear their complaint when it was brought to his office in 2019, on the grounds that no one in Pittsburgh had yet been cited in violation of the weapons ban.

Advertise with us

Passed in 2018 by former Mayor Bill Peduto and City Council, the ordinance outlaws both assault weapons and large-capacity magazines in public spaces.

Tuesday’s decision from the appellate court reversed a decision by an Allegheny County Common Pleas Court judge and said Mr. Zappala violated criminal procedure by not considering the complaint.

“Upon review, we reverse the Order and remand the matter for further proceedings,” Judge Christine Fizzano wrote in the decision.

The citizens’ team argued that Mr. Zappala had a “failure to accept the completed private criminal complaint forms and to provide a written reason for this failure” as required under state rules.

According to the court, Rule 506 allows private citizens to request the initiation of criminal proceedings against others by submitting a private criminal complaint for review by an attorney of the Commonwealth — a district attorney or the state Attorney General.

Advertise with us

The Commonwealth Court concluded its decision by sending the case back to the trial court with the requirement that Mr. Zappala either accept the citizens’ complaint or provide a written reason for denying it.

Mr. Zappala’s office put out the following response on Tuesday:

"This matter involves a City of Pittsburgh ordinance that never came into existence. It still does not exist. You cannot enforce an individual’s grievances against a law that does not exist.

“Upon remand the matter will be handled in due course."