A Fox Chapel man will serve two concurrent life sentences after pleading guilty but mentally ill in connection to two murders he committed in 2019 and 2020.
Adam Rosenberg, 23, was sentenced Friday by Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Bruce Beemer on two counts of first-degree murder and other crimes. The sentences do not allow the possibility of parole.
The charges were connected to the 2019 killing of Christian Moore-Rouse, 22, of Verona, and the killing of 28-year-old Jeremy Dentel, of Baldwin Borough, in 2020. Both victims were shot in the head.
Family members of the victims at the sentencing repeatedly referred to Rosenberg as a “monster” who took advantage of two good-natured men.
“Christian was guilty of nothing more than showing friendship and human kindness to someone who didn’t deserve it,” said T. Lee Rouse, Mr. Moore-Rouse’s mother. “Thank God the monster has finally been caught.”
She and other family members described Mr. Moore-Rouse’s various good deeds, which went back as early as age 5 when he gave a homeless man his pocket change while walking with his mother along Murray Avenue in Squirrel Hill.
Read More
He also volunteered at Jubilee soup kitchen and had dreams of starting his own business, his mother said.
Ms. Rouse urged the judge not to take the plea that was offered, and asked him to instead order Rosenberg to serve two consecutive life sentences rather than concurrent ones.
“Rosenberg is a self-proclaimed serial killer and Satan worshiper,” she told the court. “His sentence needs to be iron clad.”
She argued that Rosenberg, a white resident of the affluent Fox Chapel borough, received special treatment by the court and law enforcement due to racial bias.
Judge Beemer expressed sympathy for Ms. Rouse’s position while noting that Rosenberg had not only been diagnosed with schizophrenia and other mental health and cognitive disorders, he also received psychiatric hospitalization four times within a year of the killings.
“I’ve heard very impassioned pleas from family members, and to say that I thought about this a lot is probably an understatement of the year,” he said.
Rosenberg’s psychiatric health diagnoses and history were enough to determine him guilty but mentally ill, the judge found.
He went forward with the two concurrent life sentences because, Judge Beemer said, he did not see any legal loophole that would allow Rosenberg to serve anything other than life in the custody of the Pennsylvania Department of Corrections.
Mike Manko, a spokesman for the district attorney’s office, said the DA did not seek the death penalty against Rosenberg because he has a mental illness.
“District Attorney Zappala has always believed that the most important voice in the room is the voice of the victim and the victim's extended family,” Mr. Manko said in a statement. “This is a mom who will always grieve the loss of her son, and DA Zappala respects that. During the preparation for trial, Ms. Rouse, along with her counsel, was informed that the law requires that mental illness be considered by the court in the disposition of these matters.”
Police first arrested Rosenberg in February 2020 several days after he had killed Mr. Dentel, whose body was found in his home in Baldwin. Rosenberg was charged in Mr. Moore-Rouse’s death in May of that year after police found his remains near the killer’s Fox Chapel home. Mr. Moore-Rouse was reported missing the preceding December.
Authorities said Rosenberg killed Mr. Moore-Rouse after buying him an Uber ride to his house under the guise of smoking marijuana together.
More than a dozen people, made up of family and friends of Mr. Moore-Rouse and Mr. Dentel, submitted victim impact statements at the hearing.
Tina and Jack Dentel, Mr. Dentel’s parents, said it was hard to explain the hole that was left in their hearts and lives by the murder of their son, who loved computer programming, volunteered at the Humane Society of Pittsburgh and was active in Greek life while at the University of Pittsburgh.
“We wish every day that we could wake up from this nightmare,” Ms. Dentel said.
She described the memory of finding her son lying dead in the hallway of his home, saying the image would haunt the family forever.
“A wonderful son taken from us too soon. We will love and miss him dearly every day of our lives,” she said at the hearing.
Mr. Dentel’s brother, Josh Dentel, stood in front of the court and told Rosenberg that his lack of remorse is “the most disgusting thing I’ve ever seen in a human,” and that he contributes “nothing to society” and only detracts from the world.
“The thing that hurts most is that you took an uncle away from my son,” he said Friday.
One of Mr. Dentel’s friends, Ariella Samson, said the man never hesitated to point out the good in the world when she vented to him.
“There is clearly something wrong with this world” if her good friend is dead and Rosenberg outlives him, she said.
Dontesha Rouse, Mr. Moore-Rouse’s sister, said her brother’s loving nature allowed him to be lured into Rosenberg’s home by two things he enjoyed: video games and cannabis.
“This whole situation makes you less trusting of people, makes you question everybody’s motives and intentions,” she said.
Judge Beemer, concluding the hearing, said there was very little that he could add to what was already said in terms of the “absolute devastation” caused by Rosenberg. He said it was good that the court was able to focus on the lives that were “snuffed out casually” by the murderer.
“This word has been used and uttered a number of times today: unfair,” he said. “It is unfair that Jeremy and Christian are no longer here.”
Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.