When Andrew Clinton started visiting Pinskers Books & Judaica in 2019, store owners Baila and Dan Cohen thought he seemed to be a young man searching for something.

If that “something” was merchandise, then he must have found it: Police say Mr. Clinton, 20, of Squirrel Hill, was responsible for burglarizing the store more than a year ago, one of many reports of theft being alleged against him now.

Mr. Clinton was arrested earlier this month and is being held in the Allegheny County Jail, according to court records. He faces allegations of fraud and other criminal charges in connection with several incidents in which police say he duped members of the local Jewish community into trusting him before stealing about 300 items comprising Judaica, books, paintings and other faith-related items from them.

A specific motive is not yet known; Pittsburgh police said last week that Mr. Clinton appeared to have a genuine appreciation for Jewish culture despite repeatedly burglarizing the community leaders who took him under their wings. They said it appears he has not sold any of the items.

Advertise with us

Among the alleged victims were the Cohens, who told police that they believe Mr. Clinton was responsible for a burglary at their Murray Avenue store more than a year ago. Police recovered the items stolen from Pinskers at Mr. Clinton’s home in April. They also claim he took money from the register.

Once media coverage of Mr. Clinton’s alleged crimes began to come out last month, Mr. Cohen said he reviewed the security footage of the burglary again.

“We didn’t even make the connection until [last] week,” said Ms. Cohen.

For a little more than two years, Mr. Clinton was an occasional shopper and helping hand at Pinskers, which specializes in Jewish art, books and other items. While the Cohens said he was never a regular employee, he sometimes assisted them while they were desperate for help in the store or the associated restaurant next door.

“At a certain point we were so short-staffed that it felt like any small amount of help was worth trying,” Ms. Cohen said.

Advertise with us

Although they said Mr. Clinton was “mostly very friendly,” there was a certain amount of dishonesty from him that Mr. Cohen detected. The young man once claimed to tutor at a rate of $200 an hour, something Mr. Cohen considered unlikely.

At the time, they figured it was typical fibbing from a teen who was trying to impress people.

“You meet a lot of people like that, and you just nod your head and smile and let it pass, because you know they’re B.S.-ing and they know they’re B.S.-ing,” Mr. Cohen said.

It often seemed that Mr. Clinton was more interested in chatting than working, Ms. Cohen said, and he was sometimes disrespectful of social boundaries, making inappropriate remarks to coworkers and clientele.

He was always “cracking jokes,” Ms. Cohen said, and some of them were either “off color, or really, really, really stereotypical Jewish humor.”

Advertise with us

“I would often tell him it was more insulting than funny, but he has this idea of trying to please people and … endear himself,” she said.

The Cohens believed he was secular — he told them his father was Jewish — and that he was trying to learn more about the faith. But police last week said Mr. Clinton was not Jewish and had made no real attempts to convert, despite immersing himself in the community and culture.

Rabbi Daniel Wasserman, of the Shaare Torah Congregation, said he met Mr. Clinton in the synagogue when he was brought in by someone within the congregation last year.

He told Rabbi Wasserman that he had converted to Judaism and was trying to learn more, something that the rabbi became suspicious of over time.

“He came off to me as someone who can charm people,” he said. “A slick, sweet kid, and that can be very disarming for people.”

Advertise with us

The rabbi’s initial apprehensions were based on instinct, but after conversations with some concerned members of the community, he sat down with Mr. Clinton in the summer of 2021 to tell him that he considered him untrustworthy.

“From that point on, he did not come around the synagogue very much,” Rabbi Wasserman said. “In retrospect it makes perfect sense, because people like that, when they know they’re being watched, they don’t want to be watched.”

Rabbi Wasserman declined to detail the specific concerns that were shared with him by community members, saying the conversations were private.

But anecdotes about Mr. Clinton’s alleged series of ruses, which range from posting fake business reviews for himself under false names on Facebook, to taking checks for home improvement work that he never started, have spread throughout the Jewish social media groups he once targeted.

Pittsburgh Detective Francesco Rosato, who is investigating the case, said it was as if Mr. Clinton considered his schemes to be a full-time job.

Advertise with us

“Maybe it’s retrospect or maybe I saw it when it was happening, but there were certain things that were off,” Rabbi Wasserman said.

In one small example, the rabbi recalled trying to ask Mr. Clinton about his university courses, but the young man told him that he was unable to access his college class schedule online.

“If somebody’s in college in America in the 21st century, you got your schedule in the palm of your hand,” he said. “What does that mean you ‘can’t access it?’”

One thing that troubles Rabbi Wasserman now is that this experience may cause people in the community to be less trusting of individuals who may need help or guidance, especially as congregations continue to transition to in-person worship amid the COVID-19 pandemic.

“It’s annoying on many levels,” he said. “One level is that we are a very welcoming and open community, and I don’t want people to immediately put their guard up and not be welcoming and kind and inviting. That’s a hallmark of our community.”

Advertise with us

Initial, emotional reactions to someone who’s spent years scamming the community can cause people to put up safeguards, he said. The rabbi suggested people learn to develop and trust their instincts about people who display suspicious behavior, or to get a second opinion from someone who may be able to give guidance.

“I don’t want people to put up barriers,” he said. “I want them to be a little bit more discerning.”

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli