The former board president in the Norwin School District has sued a rival board member who had been asked to resign because of his calls for armed combat to keep former President Donald Trump in power, saying the Trump-supporting member retaliated against him and his wife by making false allegations that they are violent and threatening.
Brian Carlton, the former board president, and his wife, Margaret Carlton, a teacher in the district, filed the suit in federal court Monday against board member Robert Wayman and the Westmoreland County Republican Committee.
Mr. Wayman, a retired teacher, is an elected official with the committee.
In 2020, Mr. Carlton and three other board members asked Mr. Wayman to resign over Facebook postings on "Silent Majority 15642," a private conservative chat group that references the ZIP code for Irwin and North Huntingdon, which Norwin serves.
Mr. Wayman, who is also a former mayor of Irwin, had written on the site calling for "armed combat" if Mr. Trump didn't get re-elected, the suit says. He referred to former state Health Secretary Rachel Levine, who is a transgender woman, as "it." And he posted that "Gold Star of David coming to the mask wearers sooner than they realize" — a reference to the Star of David that the Nazis forced Jews to wear during World War II to identify them for extermination.
Mr. Wayman also said Democrats had done more to damage the U.S. than the Japanese and “German Democrats” in World War II.
At a school board meeting in September 2020, Mr. Wayman said he would seek recourse against anyone who tried to remove him from the board, according to the suit. Motions to remove Mr. Wayman failed, but the complaint says he then embarked on a revenge plot against Mr. Carlton and his wife for trying to oust him.
In April 2021, Mr. Carlton spoke at a meeting of the Republican committee to seek endorsement for re-election. He said he didn't act inappropriately, but he later received a letter from a lawyer representing the committee that he was prohibited from attending any more meetings or contacting the committee chairman. The letter also threatened Mr. Carlton with crimes if he did.
The suit says Mr. Wayman initiated the letter to "inflict emotional distress" on Mr. Carlton, who lost the election in November.
Margaret Carlton was also targeted for retribution, according to the suit. She attended a school board meeting in January of this year, after which a woman named Michelle Mendenhall said someone at Ms. Carlton's table threw something at her.
Mr. Wayman said he would do everything in his power to identify who did it and have them prosecuted. The suit says he made that statement in an attempt to identify Ms. Carlton as the culprit because she’s married to Mr. Carlton.
An investigation uncovered no evidence that anyone purposefully threw anything at Ms. Mendenhall, the suit says.
Mr. Carlton said Mr. Wayman tried to defame him in another incident in regard to his job as a teacher in the Penn Trafford district.
Last month, a group called Concerned Citizens of Penn Trafford School District sent a letter to the board saying Mr. Carlton was spreading lies and engaging in "possibly illegal behavior" because he lost the Norwin election. The letter also said people were afraid to attend Republican committee meetings because of "violence and threats" from Mr. Carlton, according to the suit.
"Plaintiff Brian Carlton made no such threats, nor has he engaged in violence of any kind," the complaint says. "These statements were, and are, patently false, defamatory to Plaintiff Brian Carlton’s character, and placed him in a false light to members of his community."
Mr. Carlton said he believes Mr. Wayman sent the letter. That’s because Mr. Wayman had told people that he would try to get Mr. Carlton removed from his teaching position, according to the suit.
The suit is seeking compensatory and other damages against Mr. Wayman.
Mr. Wayman did not respond to messages seeking a response.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.