A Pittsburgh Public Schools student was held for trial on felony aggravated assault charges for allegedly beating a classmate unconscious in school.
Quincey Garland, 18, appeared at a preliminary hearing Thursday in City Court. He is accused of beating 17-year-old Ny’Hier Williams in the hallways of Brashear High School in January.
At the hearing, prosecutors asked a substitute teacher and Ny’Hier’s mother to describe the fight and its lasting physical effects on the teen. According to security video, Mr. Garland appeared to stomp on Ny’Hier’s head even after he was unconscious.
Chata Williams, the alleged victim’s mother, told District Judge Richard King that she first saw her son at UPMC Children’s Hospital after the fight.
“When I got to the trauma unit in Children’s Hospital, he was laying there with neck brace on,” Ms. Williams said.
She said she and her family have noticed differences in his behavior following his injuries as he speaks less and wakes in the middle of the night screaming. He has since had two CT scans, physical therapy, speech therapy and concussion treatment, in addition to upcoming meetings with psychiatrists to determine if he is experiencing post-traumatic stress, she said.
Read More
Her son can no longer care for himself, Ms. Williams said. “He can’t retain memories. He can’t carry on full-fledged conversations.”
Terrence Peter Hanna Jr., Mr. Garland’s attorney, sought to paint his client’s actions as a “fight-or-flight” response to an attack from two assailants as he cross-examined Kameo Munnell, a Brashear substitute teacher who helped break up the assault.
Mr. Munnell did not confirm that characterization, describing the fight as a messy brawl. “Three students were, more or less, just going at one another,” he told the judge.
He said he saw Mr. Garland pick up Ny’Hier and slam him onto the floor before stomping on the back of his head five times.
Mr. Garland declined to comment as he left the hearing.
Eric Pettus, Ny’Hier’s cousin, said the family had “no idea” what was the cause of the alleged assault, and he added that the teen said he didn’t know why he was attacked. He said his cousin had been targeted throughout the school year.
Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.