A former Pittsburgh assistant police chief has been fired from his position as a Florida chief after only about six months on the job after an investigation into discrimination complaints against him.
Larry Scirotto was fired as chief of the Fort Lauderdale Police Department on Thursday, according to a news release from the city, The Associated Press reported.
Mr. Scirotto, 48, is gay and comes from a mixed-race background. Before his promotion to Pittsburgh assistant police chief, he had served as commander of the department’s Major Crimes Division during a 23-year tenure as a Pittsburgh officer.
The AP reported that the news release said Fort Lauderdale City Manager Chris Lagerbloom terminated Mr. Scirotto following an investigation into several discrimination complaints against him, which centered on allegations that Mr. Scirotto made hiring and promotion decisions with an improper minority-first approach.
Mr. Scirotto was sworn in as police chief in mid-August, but by November, the city had hired a law firm to investigate the complaints, according to a copy of the law firm’s report obtained by CNN.
The investigation into the bias complaints concluded that Mr. Scirotto was unfairly focused on minority candidates for jobs. It noted that he once described a wall of photos in a conference room as “too white” and said: “I’m gonna change that.”
In another incident described in the report, Mr. Scirotto allegedly overlooked a white officer with 20 years of experience, instead narrowing the choice to two men of color, of whom he asked, “Which one is Blacker?”
The report quoted the then-chief as saying he intended to “consider diversity at every opportunity.”
“Overall, there is a very divisive atmosphere within the department based on the perception the chief is intentionally using race, gender and sexual orientation as attributes necessary for promotions,” the investigative report concluded, according to the AP. “While the goal to diversify is an important and laudable goal, it must be accomplished in a legally permissible manner.”
Mr. Scirotto denied asking which candidate was “Blacker” when deciding on the promotion, but he said he did make the comment about the wall of photos being “too white” because he felt it was not reflective of the community, according to the report.
“He said the context of the comment is built around ‘how do I convince the community that we are an inclusive and diverse organization if this wall is so white?’ ” the report said.
Mr. Scirotto told CNN that he promoted 15 people, six of whom were ethnic or gender minorities, from August to November.
“None of them were promoted because they were in a protected class,” he said. “They were promoted because they were the best candidates.”
But according to the investigation, most of the 21 witnesses who spoke to investigators reported that they were “dissatisfied” with Mr. Scirotto’s approach to promotions.
The investigation concluded that “most believed that Chief Scirotto made clear his intention to promote based on race, gender or sexual orientation.”
“Some believed it was about time changes were made, but stated if promotions were based on things such as race, it would even hurt or undermine the people promoted,” the report said.
Mr. Scirotto told CNN on Saturday that the report that triggered his termination from the department was “vague on the facts” and “built on hearsay.”
He said he plans to file a wrongful termination lawsuit against the city.
“If promoting diversity is the hill I’m going to die on, I will sleep well tonight,” Mr. Scirotto told CNN. “I won’t allow them to tarnish my reputation. I won’t allow them to tarnish the work that I’ve done in the 24 years I’ve been in this profession.”
Assistant Chief Luis Alvarez has taken over as interim chief, and the police department has started a search for a new, permanent chief. The department has about 530 officers and 179 civilian employees. It serves some 186,000 residents across 36 square miles, according to its website.
Mr. Scirotto was promoted to assistant chief in Pittsburgh in July 2016. His position, the assistant chief in the Office of Professional Standards, was at the time a newly created position in charge of internal investigations, policy and training.
In 2017, Mr. Scirotto was named a finalist to become police chief of Portland, Ore., and sat for an interview with Mayor Ted Wheeler.
According to his LinkedIn profile, Mr. Scirotto was hired by Pittsburgh police in 1995 and spent just over 23 years with the department.
He retired in January 2018, according to a South Florida Sun Sentinel article from June 2021, when his hiring in Fort Lauderdale was announced.
Mr. Scirotto had moved to Dallas after retiring from Pittsburgh, the Sun Sentinel reported, but apparently decided to return to police work.
In the Sun Sentinel article, Mr. Lagerbloom — the city manager who fired Mr. Scirotto on Thursday — said he had hired Mr. Scirotto based partly on positive feedback from religious leaders, NAACP officials and Fort Lauderdale’s citizens police review board.
“We want to really have a police department that is focused on 21st-century, modern policing,” Mr. Lagerbloom told the Sun Sentinel at the time.
Mr. Scirotto promised at the time to bring accountability to the department, the Sun Sentinel added, and to treat everyone fairly.
The Associated Press, The South Florida Sun Sentinel and The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette contributed to this report.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.