Daniel Carnevale, who spent 14 years in prison on a conviction of setting a deadly fire before winning a new trial and eventually his freedom, has sued the police who investigated him and the prosecutor who put him behind bars.

Mr. Carnevale filed the complaint in U.S. District Court on Thursday, accusing the law officers of fabricating evidence, withholding evidence favorable to him and "orchestrating the use of false testimony" from an alleged jailhouse informant they had coached.

"Mr. Carnevale’s conviction was part of the disturbing resurrection of a tragic fire that occurred some 13 years prior, where there was no reliable evidence that the fire was caused by arson, let alone that it was intentionally set by Mr. Carnevale," the suit says. "Mr. Carnevale was exonerated of his wrongful conviction after serving nearly 14 years in prison."

The suit names Allegheny County Deputy District Attorney Jennifer DiGiovanni and two former Pittsburgh homicide detectives, Scott Evans and J.R. Smith.

Advertise with us

The case stems from the January 1993 fire at the Columbia House and Regal Apartments on Taylor Street in Bloomfield that killed Anita Emery, Florence Lyczko and Chris Stahlman.

ATF agents, called in to assist in the investigation, said the fire was intentionally set using lacquer thinner from a five-gallon drum recovered at the scene of the Columbia building.

Mr. Carnevale was known to hang around the area. Police questioned him and he admitted that he stole checks from resident mailboxes. But he denied setting the fire.

Police didn't arrest anyone until 13 years later, when two cold-case officers, Mr. Evans and Mr. Smith, said a new witness came forward. They arrested Mr. Carnevale and he went on trial in 2007. He was found guilty of three counts of second-degree murder and sentenced to life. He kept appealing and eventually won a new trial, but the district attorney’s office withdrew its case before it could happen and he was freed in 2020.

The Pennsylvania Innocence Project, which examined the case, said that the ATF didn't follow proper scientific procedures for determining if the cause was arson. ATF Agent William Petraitis had testified at the trial that the fire had to be arson because he'd ruled out other causes.

Advertise with us

The lawsuit repeats those claims of improper investigation by ATF.

"Petraitis never took any legitimate steps to rule out an accidental cause of the fire," it says. "Petraitis knew that there was no physical or chemical evidence supporting his conclusion that the fire was intentionally set. Without any evidence of the same, Petraitis then falsely represented to other investigators that the fire was intentionally set, and therefore, that a criminal arson and homicide investigation should follow."

The suit says that Agent Petraitis falsely said lacquer thinner was used to start the fire in the mechanical room of the Columbia apartments.

The complaint also says the two cold-case detectives never re-evaluated the cause of the fire.

Instead, they put an ad in the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review offering a reward for information. They then fabricated a statement from a witness who had said in 1993 that he saw someone leaving the building but could not identify him, according to the suit. When the detectives talked to the witness again, they said he identified the suspect as Mr. Carnevale.

Advertise with us

"Evans and Smith knew that [the witness] — for more than 13 years — never previously claimed that he knew the identity of the white male that he alleged to have seen leaving the courtyard of the Columbia on January 17, 1993,” the suit says.

The complaint also says that Ms. DiGiovanni encouraged Mr. Evans and Mr. Smith to solicit false statements from a jailhouse informant she had used in the past, according to the suit, to falsify statements to bolster weak cases or prosecute innocent people.

The suit says the three met with the informant to provide him with details of the case. In exchange for the false testimony and Ms. DiGiovanni and the two detectives promised leniency on two pending criminal cases, a deal they concealed from the defense.

In the end, Mr. Carnevale won a new trial. But when the Innocence Project presented additional witness reports that had never been turned over, the district attorney's office withdrew the case.

Mr. Carnevale was released in March 2020.

Advertise with us

The suit raises claims of malicious prosecution in violation of the Fourth Amendment, fabrication of evidence in violation of the 14th Amendment and conspiracy.

Mike Manko, spokesman for the district attorney, said Friday that the office is reviewing the complaint.