Two men who ran a McKees Rocks pizza shop avoided prison on Tuesday when a federal judge gave them probation instead of the prison terms the U.S. attorney's office wanted for tax evasion.

U.S. District Judge Marilyn Horan gave Jakhongir Babajanov and Rasul Rustamov, owners of Gavino's Pizzeria, three years of probation, the first year of which will be on home detention.

She ordered them both to pay $121,000 in restitution to the IRS. Their lawyers indicated they have already paid back the money.

Babajanov, 39, a Carnegie resident and native of Uzbekistan who arrived in the U.S. in 2004, and Rustamov, 32, who emigrated from Russia at age 15 and lives in Clairton, waived indictment in October and pleaded guilty to tax evasion and conspiracy following an investigation by the criminal division of the IRS.

Advertise with us

The men, who opened the shop in 2011, evaded taxes from 2016 to 2018 by not reporting cash receipts and paying employees in cash. They kept multiple sets of books, according to charges filed last year, in which they concealed their true income from cash.

When agents raided the shop in May 2019, Babajanov went to a Federal Express store to shred one of his notebooks, according to court papers. Rustamov deleted sales information from the business computer.

Both men, who have young families and no prior criminal history, apologized for what they'd done and characterized the tax scheme as a "mistake" they won't repeat.

They and their lawyers asked for probation instead of the 12 to 18 months called for in federal sentencing guidelines so they can stay out of prison and work to support their families.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Jim Wilson objected to the description of tax evasion as a "mistake," like adding up some numbers in the wrong column on a tax return. Rather, he said their crime was a series of "deliberate choices" over time to defraud the IRS.

Advertise with us

"This is the 180-degree polar opposite of ignorance of the law," Mr. Wilson said.

He said that while the case is not large compared to many tax cases seen in the federal courts, it's the kind of crime that erodes the ability of the government to collect taxes and provide services for American citizens.

The judge sided with the defense in granting downward variances for both men and letting them stay out of prison.

She made it clear that she was giving them a break and warned them not to get in trouble again.