A man accused and then dismissed by a judge in the killing of six people in Wilkinsburg in 2016 has sued the investigating police and their bosses on grounds of malicious prosecution.
Robert Thomas, 33, who spent four years in jail awaiting trial, filed the suit Wednesday in federal court against Allegheny County, various detectives and their supervisors, and the former county police superintendent, Coleman McDonough.
Thomas and Cheron Shelton were accused of gunning down the six at a Wilkinsburg cookout in March 2016.
Detectives said Thomas fired at the crowd with a pistol to flush the victims towards the back porch, where Shelton shot them with an assault rifle.
In February 2020, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Edward Borkowski dismissed Thomas from the case for lack of evidence as the trial was about to start.
The judge granted a motion by Thomas' lawyer to throw out the charges after the district attorney's office said it would not be calling three cooperating jailhouse witnesses.
Read More
Shelton went on trial by himself and was acquitted. A federal grand jury later indicted him for possession of a gun unrelated to the murders, and he went to prison.
Thomas' suit says police were under pressure to arrest someone for the murders and "engaged in multiple acts of misconduct to cobble together a case by any means necessary."
He and his lawyers, Paul Jubas and Max Petrunya, said police brought charges based "solely on unsupported and unsubstantiated statements from unreliable confidential jailhouse informants."
The suit says Thomas was deliberately housed in jail in the same pod as a "prolific and unreliable" informant who had received five confessions from homicide suspects dating to 2014.
The complaint also says police relied on information from that man and two other jailed informants but ignored exclusionary evidence indicating Thomas could not have done the shooting.
"Defendants never produced any physical evidence or eyewitness testimony that the Plaintiff Robert Thomas committed the crimes charged," the suit says.
The suit also says police withheld exculpatory evidence in violation of the U.S. Constitution.
Thomas alleges numerous civil rights violations, including malicious prosecution, civil rights conspiracy and failure to intervene on the part of police supervisors.
"Mr. Thomas, along with Cheron Shelton, is innocent of all claims brought against him related to the Wilkinsburg Massacre," the suit says. "He had nothing to do with the crime and has no knowledge of the real perpetrator or perpetrators."
In addition to the county and the ex-superintendent, the defendants are county Officers Scott Scherer, Stephen Hitchings, Todd Dolfi, Thomas Foley, Patrick Miller and Patrick Kinavey. A Pittsburgh police detective, Andrew Miller, is also named.
The complaint is seeking compensatory and punitive damages.
The county does not comment on pending litigation.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.