A 19-year-old Pittsburgh man was arrested last week and charged with criminal homicide in a fatal shooting in the city’s Allentown neighborhood.

James Linnert, of St. Clair, was charged in the killing a man in the 800 block of Loyal Way on Jan. 20. Joshua Hamilton, 19, of Carnegie, was identified as the victim by the Medical Examiner’s Office.

A witness, who is not named in the criminal complaint, told police that Mr. Linnert and Mr. Hamilton brought firearms to the Loyal Way residence because they were supposed to go to a shooting range.

While the witness was upstairs with a 4-month-old child, an argument broke out between the two teens and escalated, according to the complaint. The witness said they heard Mr. Linnert grunt before hearing a loud bang.

Advertise with us

When the witness went downstairs to see what had happened, Mr. Hamilton was on the kitchen floor. Mr. Linnert said Mr. Hamilton pointed a weapon at him.

Not knowing whether the firearm was loaded, Mr. Linnert attempted to disarm Mr. Hamilton, he alleged. As he pushed the gun away, the shotgun fired and struck Mr. Hamilton, he told the witness.

But analysis by the Medical Examiner’s Office determined the shot could not have occurred at such close contact because of the distance between the shotgun pellets.

Mr. Hamilton could not have pulled the trigger on the shotgun, as Mr. Linnert claimed, and suffered the wounds he did, according to the complaint. The manner of death was ruled a homicide.

Mr. Linnert is incarcerated at the Allegheny County Jail. He was denied bail by Magisterial District Judge Robert Ravenstahl Jr., and a preliminary hearing has been scheduled for March 11.

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli