The family of a Pittsburgh man killed last month in Venango County criticized Wednesday the state police investigation with no one yet arrested for his death.
Peter Bernardo Spencer, 29, was shot and killed at a cabin in the 200 block of Carls Road in Rockland Township on Dec. 12. On Wednesday, his family and their attorney criticized the Pennsylvania State Police’s handling of the investigation, saying it lacked transparency and communication with the family.
Although a 25-year-old man and three other people were detained by troopers following the killing, no one has been charged.
“We’re extremely surprised that nobody was charged,” said Paul Jubas, the attorney representing Spencer’s family. “We’re extremely disappointed that, thus far, law enforcement, the district attorney’s office, as well as the state police, have not made any substantive comments to the family as to what is really happening in this investigation.”
The family hired Dr. Cyril Wecht to conduct a private autopsy on Spencer’s body, but they said their attempts to obtain photos and reports from the Venango County Coroner’s Office have been met with resistance.
The Venango County Coroner and the Pennsylvania State Police did not immediately respond to requests for comment Wednesday evening.
Read More
Spencer’s mother, Icilda Spencer-Hunter, said she has doubts about how the investigation is being handled.
“There are so many things that explode in my mind, but can I speak them out?” she said. “No, I can only go over them in my mind.”
Spencer pleaded guilty in 2016 and 2019 to drug and gun possession charges, according to court records, and was sentenced to three years of probation.
Ms. Spencer-Hunter said she believed if her son was the perpetrator of a killing, he would have been treated more harshly than the men who were detained last month.
“I would not see him,” she said. “He would not have come out [of jail] until this investigation is finished. It would have been locked in his face, the key would have been thrown out, and maybe I could not speak to him either. So what applies to him should apply to everyone.”
The investigation was criticized by local activists and civil rights groups shortly after details of the killing were released. It was the subject of a letter sent Dec. 26 by Black Political Empowerment Project Chairman and CEO Tim Stevens demanding the “immediate arrest and prosecution of all involved in the death of Peter Bernardo Spencer.”
The letter, addressed to U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland, Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf and the Venango County DA’s office among others, continued: “We demand the immediate investigation of this murder by the Venango County district attorney, the U.S. attorney general, and the PA state attorney general, and that this murder be considered as a hate crime and an act of domestic terrorism.”
Mr. Jubas, likewise, said he wanted the involvement of Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro and federal authorities such as the FBI. He also wanted the killing to be investigated as a hate crime. He noted that state police Troop E Major Case Team, which responds to hate- and bias-related crimes, according to the agency’s website, was notified of the incident.
“All we’re asking for is some dignity and some respect and some transparency in regards to what happened to the father of this woman’s unborn child,” he said, referring to Spencer’s fiancé, Carmela King, who was present at the press conference.
Ms. King declined to make comments during the conference.
“It’s inappropriate to not have any kind of discussion with the family about what happened,” Mr. Jubas said. “It’s incredibly inappropriate.”
Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter @MickStinelli







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.