Another doctor who ripped off Medicare in a criminal kickback scheme in cahoots with a convicted Greensburg lab owner was sentenced Tuesday to probation, including two years of home detention, and ordered to pay more than half a million dollars in restitution.

John Baird, 55, a pain doctor in Louisville, Ky., had pleaded guilty in 2018 to conspiracy to defraud the United States in receiving kickbacks from William Hughes, owner of Universal Oral Fluid Labs.

U.S. District Judge Kim Gibson, presiding in Johnstown, Pa., gave Baird five years of probation and ordered him to pay $567,609 to Medicare.

Baird was one of several doctors in Pennsylvania, Florida and Indiana who got kickbacks from Hughes for referring patients to his lab.

Advertise with us

U.S. District Judge David Cercone in July sentenced Hughes, 74, to two months in prison plus a year of home detention and ordered him to pay $1.6 million in restitution to Medicaid. Hughes also forfeited more than $700,000 in seized assets.

Baird entered into a deal in 2012 to refer his patients' lab tests to Hughes in exchange for money. He and Hughes tried to hide what they were doing by calling it a "Joint Venture Agreement." Medicare was the victim because it paid for the testing.

Baird made $300,000 a year as a doctor, said Assistant U.S. Attorney Eric Olshan, but wanted more. Hughes ended up paying him $560,000 in kickbacks.

"The defendant engaged in a criminal conspiracy for over a year and walked away with enormous kickbacks for doing nothing other than making referrals," Mr. Olshan said. "This yearlong pattern of conduct reflects an utter disregard and disrespect for the law."

What's more, Mr. Olshan said, soliciting kickbacks "puts profits over patient care and drives up health care costs, all at the expense of the fair administration of health care law in the United States."

Advertise with us

The sentencing guideline range was 37 to 46 months behind bars.

But Baird's lawyer, Steven Romines, asked for probation, saying his client cooperated in the investigation, was only involved with Hughes for a year and isn't likely to commit crimes in the future. He said Baird's problems started in 2012 when the Kentucky medical board suspended his prescription-writing abilities. His income suffered, and he also had marital and health issues, Mr. Romines said.

While Baird did accept kickbacks, his lawyer said, none of his patients were affected.

Hughes had pleaded guilty in connection to a deal with another criminal Kentucky doctor.

From 2011 to 2013, his lab entered into a kickback scheme with Varanise Booker, a Louisville psychiatrist. Hughes had also faced a prison range under the sentencing guidelines, and his lawyer argued for probation. In that case, Judge Cercone did not impose a term within the guidelines but did give Hughes two months in prison, saying white-collar criminals shouldn't be allowed to just pay fines and restitution and get home detention so they can sit in their big houses and "watch reruns of 'Gunsmoke.'"

Advertise with us

"Without some sting of a sentence, the message is, 'Crime does pay,'" he said.

Booker, 66, pleaded guilty in October to health care fraud and is awaiting sentencing.

Several other doctors have been ensnared in the scheme. In 2017, Judge Gibson gave John Johnson, a pain doctor in Hollidaysburg, seven years in federal prison for accepting kickbacks and income tax evasion.

Others paid to settle civil claims under a deal with the Justice Department. Robert Fetchero, a Jeannette osteopath, paid $200,000. Sridhar Pinnamaneni, an orthopedic surgeon in Windermere, Fla., paid $370,000. And Thelma Green-Mack, a physiatrist in Indianapolis, paid $130,000.