HARRISBURG — A father and daughter who were severely injured when a falling tree crushed their car as they drove on a highway in Beaver County can’t sue PennDOT over the incident, a state appeals court panel ruled Wednesday.

The tree was 3 feet outside PennDOT’s right-of-way when it toppled onto state road 151 in Hopewell, Judge Ellen Ceisler noted in the Commonwealth Court’s opinion.

Fred Polesky Jr. and his daughter Gabriella appealed to Judge Ceisler’s court after a Beaver County judge dismissed PennDOT as a defendant in their lawsuit over the July 2017 tree fall.

Judge Ceisler agreed with the county judge that PennDOT is immune from such suits, especially in this case where it had no legal control over the property where the tree stood before it tumbled.

Advertise with us

The Poleskys claimed in their suit that PennDOT was liable for their injuries because it has a duty to ensure that trees on the sides of its roads are trimmed or felled if they pose a danger to passing vehicles.

They insisted PennDOT knew or should have known that the tree that hit their SUV was in danger of toppling onto the road.

A tree expert the Poleskys cited concluded the tree that fell on them “had been damaged several years before the accident by negligent trimming, which caused the tree to decay and eventually collapse.”

A PennDOT official said the tree in question “was so far off the roadway, you couldn’t see it from the road” and that PennDOT would not have trimmed it.

Although they had no luck in suing PennDOT, the Poleskys did reach a settlement with the 97-year-old owner of the land where the tree had stood, Judge Ceisler noted.