The largest physical therapy business in Erie, its owners and 18 employees submitted at least $22 million in fraudulent bills to insurance for treatment by unlicensed technicians, false bills for treatment by therapists who were on vacation and bogus bills for excess hours by booking as many as four patients at a time for a single therapist, according to a federal grand jury.

Hertel & Brown Physical & Aquatic Therapy was named Tuesday as a defendant along with 20 individuals, 18 of them from northwestern Pennsylvania, including owners and founders Aaron Hertel and Michael Robert Brown.

Hertel lives in North East, Pa., and Brown in Erie.

The fraud spans 2007 until this year, prosecutors said, and occurred at several Hertel & Brown locations in the Erie area.

Advertise with us

The investigation, spearheaded by the FBI along with other federal and state agencies, first became public when agents raided the practice in February.

According to the indictment, Hertel & Brown used unlicensed technicians to perform physical therapy and billed the treatment as if a licensed therapist had done it. The practice allowed the unlicensed technicians to log into the treatment documentation system, called WebPT, and document treatment as if a therapist had performed the service.

In addition, the licensed employees regularly recorded and billed for treatment far in excess of the actual treatment time and rarely used group therapy codes when billing even when group billing codes were the only appropriate ones, the grand jury said.

Hertel & Brown also regularly billed treatment time using the name and credentials of therapists who were on vacation and in some cases out of the country, the indictment says. For example, on Feb. 25, 2019, the practice submitted 18 billing claims for payment using the name and credentials of co-owner Michael Brown when he was on vacation in the Dominican Republic. On Aug. 12, 2019, the practice submitted 22 claims for Julie Ann Johnson when she was on vacation in Cancun, the grand jury said.

The indictment recounts numerous other examples of billings for vacationing therapists.

Advertise with us

The practice allowed therapy assistants and unlicensed employees to treat patients with insurance that only reimbursed for treatment performed by a therapist, then covered up the identity of the person who actually treated the patient by removing the name of that person from the documentation records.

Finally, the grand jury said Hertel & Brown and some employees manually changed the patient schedule after the fact to conceal that Medicare patients were scheduled at the same time as other patients.

The practice did that to hide the fact that Medicare patients did not have one-on-one treatment with a therapist as billed and as required by Medicare, the grand jury said.

The practice and several accused co-conspirators, including the two owners, "regularly emphasized patient volume and provided bonuses and compensation to employees that were dependant on patient volume," according to the charges.

The owners also tracked the number of referrals by doctors and provided "gifts and incentives" to doctors with the highest referral rates, the grand jury said. If a doctor's referrals dropped off, Hertel & Brown stopped giving the gifts.

Advertise with us

The indictment includes forfeiture allegations in which prosecutors seek to confiscate Hertel & Brown's Fairview office and all of its physical therapy and office equipment, along with two homes in North East and Erie.

In a statement announcing the charges, Acting U.S. Attorney Stephen Kaufman described the conduct of Hertel & Brown as a "brazen fraud scheme that bilked insurance companies and the government through blatantly false billings."

Mike Nordwall, agent in charge of the Pittsburgh FBI, said the people charged were in business to "make a quick buck" and violated the ethical standards of health care professionals.

In addition to Hertel and Brown, the other defendants are: Sarah Elizabeth Bailey of Erie; Jessica Jeanne Morphy of Erie; Jacqueline Renee Exley of Erie; Julie Ann Johnson of Erie; Bobby Lee Rainey of Erie; Steve Michael Bauer of Erie; Austin John Dudenhoefer of Erie; Philip Dale Sorensen Jr. of Erie; Patricia Susan Berchtold of Melbourne, Fla.; Jeremy Richard Bowes of Erie; Jennifer Marie Larmon of Waterford, Pa.; Travis Walter Litz of Erie; Erin Marie Riffe of Conneaut, Ohio; Abigayle Jane Fachetti of Erie; Lori Lynn Goss of Waterford; Marissa Sue Hull of Waterford; Justin Charles Burger of Erie; and Carl William Lewis Jr. of Lake City, Pa.

Mr. Hertel's lawyer, Charbel Latouf, said Hertel would would fight the charges.

Advertise with us

"My client maintains his innocence and will defend against the allegations contained in the indictment," he said in an email.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com