The Supreme Court told a lower court Monday to take another look at whether the health insurance plans of certain religious organizations in New York must include coverage for abortions.
New York requires employer health insurance plans of a certain size to cover medically necessary abortions. There is an exception for religious entities whose purpose is to inculcate religious values and that employ and serve primarily those of the same religion.
But it doesn’t provide the exemption to religious organizations with a broader religious mission, or if they employ and serve those outside the religion.
The case was decided before the court settled a dispute last year in favor of religious groups that had been banned from providing foster care vetting for the city of Philadelphia. The Supreme Court said lower courts should take that into account.
Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito Jr. and Neil Gorsuch said they would have accepted the case now.
The challenge brought by the Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany and organizations of other religions says the lack of an exception for such groups requires them to “participate” in abortion.
“The consequences could hardly be more severe,” said the brief from the religious organizations, written by former Trump administration solicitor general Noel Francisco. “New York churches and religious ministries will be forced to cooperate in what they consider to be grave evil — or stop operating.”
The requirement was upheld by New York state courts, and the state told the Supreme Court that the regulation does not violate the organizations’ religious freedom.
Transgender rights
The Supreme Court turned down the chance to consider whether a Catholic hospital can be sued over refusing a transgender patient treatment the hospital says would violate its core religious beliefs.
A California court said Evan Minton could pursue his lawsuit after a hospital canceled a scheduled hysterectomy upon learning days before that he was transgender. The operation was part of his treatment for gender dysphoria, a condition in which an individual’s gender identity does not conform to the sex they were assigned at birth.
Justices Thomas, Alito and Gorsuch said they would have accepted the case.
Mr. Minton was scheduled to receive the operation in 2016 at Mercy San Juan Medical Center near Sacramento, a hospital in the Dignity Health chain. After complaints from his physician and media reports about the denial, the operation was performed several days later at a Methodist hospital that is part of the chain.
Mr. Minton sued, and the California Court of Appeals said he could go forward with his claim that Mercy’s actions violated the state’s civil rights law, which protects LGBTQ people.
The California court said Mr. Minton had shown adequately for purposes of a lawsuit that the hospital denied him treatment because he is transgender, and thus denied him the “full and equal” access to medical care that California law requires.
The judges turned aside the hospital’s claim that it was protected by the Constitution’s guarantee of free exercise of religion and free speech.
Mr. Minton’s case was one of those cited when the Trump administration’s Health and Human Services Department issued the Refusal of Care Rule, which aimed to support religious entities that said their beliefs would be violated by providing certain care to LGBTQ people.
A judge stopped the rule before it went into effect, and the Biden administration has disavowed it.
Secret surveillance
The court also declined to decide whether the public has at least a limited right to review the decisions of a largely secret federal surveillance court whose influence has been growing.
The justices turned down a request from the ACLU and news operations to review a ruling that denied access to decisions of the Federal Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISC). That court said it lacked authority even to consider a public claim under the First Amendment to its secret decision-making.
Justices Gorsuch and Sonia Sotomayor said they would have taken the case.
“On the government’s view, literally no court in this country has the power to decide whether citizens possess a First Amendment right of access to the work of our national security courts,” Justice Gorsuch wrote, adding: “If these matters are not worthy of our time, what is?”
Murder appeal denied
The Supreme Court also declined to hear the appeal of a former Connecticut nurse convicted of killing and dismembering his college student girlfriend in 2013.
Jermain Richards, of Bridgeport, was convicted of murder and sentenced to 60 years in prison for the killing of Alyssiah Marie Wiley, a 20-year-old sophomore at Eastern Connecticut State University. Her partial remains were found about a mile and a half from Richards’ home.
The conviction came after two previous trials ended in hung juries.
Richards’ lawyers asked the Supreme Court to decide whether the U.S. Constitution’s double jeopardy clause bars the retrial of criminal defendants after previous trials ended with hung juries. The court did not explain why it declined to hear the case, under standard practice.
The Connecticut Supreme Court upheld Richards’ conviction earlier this year, rejecting arguments that there was not sufficient evidence.
Prosecutors said Richards, now 38, killed Wiley as she tried to break off their relationship. Wiley’s family and friends testified Richards was jealous, possessive and had been physically violent with her.
Richards’ lawyers said there was no physical evidence in the case, nothing to show where or when Wiley was killed and no eyewitnesses.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.