A Pittsburgh homicide detective said Wednesday that he read accused Tree of Life synagogue shooter Robert Bowers his Miranda rights in an ambulance after he’d been shot by police and that Mr. Bowers then “lawyered up,” so the officer didn't ask any questions about the shooting.

Testifying in a federal suppression hearing for Mr. Bowers, Detective Robert Shaw said he climbed into the ambulance taking Mr. Bowers to the hospital and read him his rights from a printed card.

“He said that he believed he should speak to a lawyer first,” said Detective Shaw. "He understood what I was saying.”

Detective Shaw said he engaged Mr. Bowers in small talk on the ride and at one point asked if there were any bombs or other devices left at Tree of Life that could further injure anyone, but he didn't interrogate him about the massacre.

Advertise with us

“Once he lawyered up, I’m not going to ask him anything incriminating,” the officer said.

The detective was testifying in the second day of a hearing to determine if anti-Semitic or incriminating statements that police say Mr. Bowers made after the killings should be suppressed.

Mr. Bowers is charged with gunning down 11 worshippers at Tree of Life on Oct. 27, 2018, and wounding several police officers. The Justice Department is seeking the federal death penalty. The defense wants a plea deal for life in prison.

Mr. Bowers’ lawyers are asking U.S. District Judge Donetta Ambrose to toss his statements on the grounds that they were made under duress and that police violated his rights by coercing him.

On Tuesday, SWAT Officer Clint Thimons said that after Mr. Bowers had battled police in two gunfights and been wounded, the officer asked him why he had gone on his rampage.

Advertise with us

“He said that ‘he's had enough. Jews were killing our children.’ He ‘couldn't take it anymore and all Jews had to die,’ ” he said Mr. Bowers told him.

Other officers heard him make similar statements and the SWAT commander at the scene, Stephen Mescan, reported on the air that Mr. Bowers said “All these Jews have to die” as he crawled out of his hiding place.

Wednesday’s testimony was focused on Bowers’ ambulance ride and his treatment at the hospital.

Public defenders Elisa Long and Ashwin Cattamanchi questioned police officers and paramedics in an effort to show that Mr. Bowers was in pain while being questioned.

Most of the officers said he complained of some pain but was calm, alert and responsive.

Advertise with us

Detective Shaw said Mr. Bowers told him a few times that his wounds hurt but said he wasn't “screaming or in agony.”

An FBI agent, Matthew Patcher, also rode in the ambulance and said Mr. Bowers was groaning but appeared to be “willing himself” to control the pain.

Other witnesses said Mr. Bowers was alert in the ambulance and at the hospital and was able to provide his name, date of birth and other biographical data.

Prosecutors presented a bodycam video of the ambulance ride. In it, a paramedic is heard asking Mr. Bowers his name and Detective Shaw is heard asking questions about how he is doing. The detective said, however, that he gave his Miranda warning before the camera was turned on.

Detective Shaw said he did ask Mr. Bowers if there were any items at Tree of Life that could hurt anyone else.

Advertise with us

“He said there was nothing,” Detective Shaw said. “He just itemized his weaponry.”

Those weapons were an AR-15 assault-style rifle, three handguns and, in his car, a shotgun.

Detective Shaw said he asked about possible bombs or other threats because of safety concerns to officers still at the scene, but he said his questions were not an interrogation about the shootings.

Asked by the defense if he was trying to build a rapport with Mr. Bowers to get him to talk without an attorney present, he said that was not his intention. Instead, he said he was being “human.”

He said he read Mr. Bowers his Miranda rights a second time at the hospital and that Mr. Bowers again invoked his right to a lawyer.

Advertise with us

Detective Shaw said he honored that request, saying the right to remain silent “has to be respected.”

The detective said Mr. Bowers appeared responsive with medical staff at the hospital.

“He just seemed like a cooperative, nice, normal guy,” he said.

Neither side presented argument after the hearing. Instead, Judge Ambrose asked the parties to file briefs outlining their positions. She gave them 30 days to file after receiving a transcript of the hearing.