HARRISBURG — A state appeals court panel has overturned the life without parole sentence of a Washington, Pa., woman who has spent the last 17 years behind bars for murdering her newborn baby.

In sum, the Superior Court judges found that Jessica Rizor’s attorney was ineffective for not advising her to take a plea deal that would have allowed her to get out of prison in as little 5½ years.

Instead, Rizor when to trial and was convicted by a Washington County jury on charges of first-degree murder, concealing the death of a child and abuse of a corpse.

As Senior Judge James Gardner Colins noted in the state court’s opinion, Rizor, now 44, concealed her pregnancy from her husband and the rest of her family until she gave birth on Thanksgiving morning of 2004.

Advertise with us

She then wrapped the live baby girl in plastic bags and left her to suffocate in the trash, investigators said. They said Rizor’s husband found the corpse when she asked him to take out the garbage.

Rizor later gave a full statement to the police.

The plea agreement she turned down called for her to plead guilty but mentally ill to third-degree murder in exchange for a prison sentence of 5½ to 30 years.

On appeal, Rizor contended her lawyer did not adequately advise her regarding that deal or of her chances of making a successful mental health defense at trial. She testified during a court hearing in 2018 that she would have taken the deal had she been properly advised that her chances of succeeding at trial were practically nil, Judge Colins noted.

Judge Colins agreed with Rizor’s contention that her lawyer failed to advise her that he could make no reasonable defense, especially since the trial judge had barred him from presenting two psychiatric witnesses who would have been key to her case.

The Superior Court’s decision means Rizor can opt either for a new trial or to negotiate another plea agreement, one that could possibly result in her prompt release from prison.