A Crafton Heights man accused of setting a fire Sunday behind a popular Swissvale hot dog shop was arrested Tuesday in West Virginia.
Joseph Pepp, 28, is charged with three counts of aggravated arson, arson endangering property and criminal mischief after police say he intentionally started a fire early Sunday in a commercial recycling bin located behind D’s Six Pax & Dogz on South Braddock Avenue.
Mr. Pepp had reportedly been drinking with friends that night at a neighboring bar, The Loft.
The Swissvale Fire Department responded at 2:31 a.m. Sunday to the fire, which was located in the alley behind D’s. Employees had unsuccessfully tried to put out the fire before police arrived, the criminal complaint said.
Fire officials were able to extinguish the blaze by 2:55 a.m., police said. After viewing surveillance footage and speaking to witnesses, the Allegheny County Fire Marshal’s Office determined Mr. Pepp started the fire.
There were no reported injuries, and estimated damages are at about $30,000, the complaint said.
The Wheeling Police Department in West Virginia captured and arrested Mr. Pepp two days later, officials said.
Mr. Pepp was found around 1 a.m. Tuesday at a motel after Wheeling police officers stopped him and checked his identification. According to Michael Roxey, a spokesman for the Wheeling Police Department, police had been posted outside the Knights Inn in the 1100 block of Main Street watching for drug activity and prostitution.
“Police saw him go into one of the rooms they were watching, and he got about a block away before they stopped him and ran his ID,” Mr. Roxey said Wednesday. “The details came up that he was wanted in Pittsburgh, so he was arrested. [Mr. Pepp] had gotten off a Greyhound bus and told police he was traveling and waiting for his next bus. He was found with .18 grams of fentanyl on him.”
Mr. Pepp is currently being held at the Northern Regional Correctional Facility and Jail in Moundsville, W.Va., Mr. Roxey said. Details regarding when Mr. Pepp will be transferred back to Pittsburgh were not provided.
Sunday’s fire in Regent Square occurred after Mr. Pepp had a night of drinking with friends, police said.
Mr. Pepp and two others had been drinking Saturday night at The Loft — located next door to D’s — when Mr. Pepp became upset after being denied more drinks by a bartender, according to the complaint.
The bartender informed Mr. Pepp and his friends they had already made the last call for drinks and informed Mr. Pepp he was intoxicated, the complaint said.
Mr. Pepp then “slammed his fists against the bar, grinded his teeth” and yelled at the bartender, police said. Mr. Pepp and his friends were asked to leave and were escorted out, police said.
Surveillance footage showed that minutes later, at 2:18 a.m., a white man with shoulder-length hair, wearing a light-colored cowboy hat — later identified to police as Mr. Pepp — set fire to “cardboard like material” located inside the dumpster.
The blaze extended to a nearby telephone pole and into the back of the D’s. Police said there were three people inside the building at the time of the fire, but they escaped unharmed.
According to a note posted Tuesday onto the restaurant Facebook account, D’s will be closed for at least a week.
“Definitely didn’t want to have to do this but we are going to have to call it for the rest of this week at least,” the Facebook post reads. “If anything changes we will let you know. This is a whole process that we are figuring out as we go.”
Correction: This version corrects the borough where the restaurant is located.
Lacretia Wimbley: lwimbley@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1510 or on Twitter @Wimbleyjourno.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.