A federal appellate court has overturned a Pittsburgh judge who dismissed a lawsuit brought by a former county jail captain on his claim that he was fired because he complained that another officer made racist comments toward him because his grand-niece is biracial.

The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday ruled that U.S. District Judge J. Nicholas Ranjan was wrong to grant summary judgment for Allegheny County in a case brought in 2017 by Jeffrey Kengerski against the county and Allegheny Jail Warden Orlando Harper.

Mr. Kengerski, a former captain fired in 2015, said in his suit that a co-worker, Major Robyn McCall, had referred to his niece as "a little monkey" and then sent a series of texts to him with racially offensive comments about his black co-workers. Mr. Kengerski and Ms. McCall are white.

Ms. McCall retired in 2015 and Mr. Kengerski was terminated a few month later.

Advertise with us

In its opinion, the 3rd Circuit said that discriminating against someone because of their relationship with a person of a different race is illegal and sent the case back to Judge Ranjan.

The county had argued that Mr. Kengerski was fired for misconduct regarding sexual harassment claims, but Mr. Kengerski said that was a pretext for the real reason, which he said was reporting Ms. McCall's behavior.

Judge Ranjan granted the county's motion for summary judgment last year, saying that Mr. Kengerski did not have a reasonable claim for retaliation. The judge said that while Mr. Kengerski was correct to report the racist comments and texts, Ms. McCall's actions did not rise to an illegal employment practice.

"Because Mr. Kengerski's complaint had nothing to do with an unlawful employment practice, his claim for retaliation" fails under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, the judge had ruled.

Writing for a three-judge 3rd Circuit panel, Judge Thomas Ambro said the law protects employees from retaliation when they believe that behavior at work violates the statute.

Advertise with us

"As relevant here, harassment against an employee because he associates with a person of another race, such as a family member, may violate Title VII by creating a hostile work environment," the judge wrote.

He said the circuit's ruling doesn't mean Mr. Kengerski will win, because the county says he was fired for other reasons, but the case will now return to Judge Ranjan to reconsider Mr. Kengerski's claim.

In his original complaint, Mr. Kengerski said that in 2014 he was discussing his grand-niece, Jaylynn, in the presence of Ms. McCall, then a captain, and other officers. He said he and his wife were preparing to take Jaylynn under their care because her mother was unable to care for her.

According to the complaint, Ms. McCall asked, "What kind of name is Jaylynn? Is she black?" and then said that Mr. Kengerski "will be that guy in the store with a little monkey on his hip" like another jail officer with a biracial child.

Mr. Kengerski also included in the suit text messages that McCall sent him with unflattering images of blacks and Asians with offensive captions that compared them to black and Asian jail employees. Mr. Kengerski complained about the "monkey" comment and the texts and said he was being harassed. He also said Ms. McCall, who later became a major, had punished him by putting him on the night shift.

Advertise with us

Ms. McCall was placed on leave in May 2015 and resigned three months later, although Mr. Kengerski said her resignation was forced because of his complaint.

Mr. Kengerski was fired in November 2015 after the county said he had told two subordinate officers to lie on reports about alleged sexual harassment incidents.

The circuit judges noted that the county "incredibly attempts to argue" that the monkey comment was "merely a harmless 'zoomorophism'," but Judge Ambrose said it was clearly used in a racist manner.

Judge Ranjan also said it was racist but also concluded that it was unreasonable for Mr. Kengerski to claim that a single discriminatory remark would be enough to create a hostile work environment.

Judge Ambro and his colleagues disagreed, saying Ms. McCall's subsequent texts over the following months could have caused Mr. Kengerski to believe they were directed at him.

"McCall’s conduct was serious enough that a reasonable employee in Kengerski’s shoes could have believed his work environment was hostile," Judge Ambro wrote.