The former owner of a Westmoreland County medical testing lab at the heart of a kickback scheme involving doctors in several states was sentenced Tuesday to two months in prison and a year of home detention on a conspiracy conviction.

U.S. District Judge David Cercone imposed that term on William Hughes, 74, who formerly ran Universal Oral Fluid Labs in Greensburg. The judge also ordered Hughes to pay $1.6 million in restitution to Medicaid and a $5,000 fine.

Hughes pleaded guilty last summer to conspiracy.

From October 2011 to August 2013, Hughes and his lab entered into a kickback scheme with a Kentucky psychiatrist, Varanise Booker, owner of Family and Children Behavioral Services in Louisville. Hughes paid Booker to refer her patients, many of them juveniles, to his lab for drug testing services in exchange for cash. The Medicaid program paid for the testing.

Advertise with us

From September 2012 to August 2013, Universal received $1.6 million from Medicaid based on the referrals.

Hughes faced a sentencing range of 37 to 46 months. His lawyer, Doug Sughrue, asked the judge for probation. He largely blamed the doctors and said that Universal's testing was legitimate. He also said the scheme didn't really hurt anyone and that his client is older and has medical problems so shouldn't be locked up.

For his part, Hughes issued a one-line apology to his family and employees.

But Eric Olshan, the prosecutor, said that the scheme "undermined the integrity" of the Medicaid program in that doctors had the incentive to submit tests for kickbacks.

"He can't deny that that incentive existed," Mr. Olshan said.

Advertise with us

He also said that Hughes' role was not an "arms-length involvement" but a criminal conspiracy that made him wealthy. He asked for at least some jail time as a deterrent to others who might try something similar. Without that deterrent, he said, white-collar criminals can essentially pay their way out of prosecutions.

Judge Cercone agreed. While he acknowledged that the two months in prison might seem lenient, he denied the probation request because he felt some prison time is necessary to set an example. Not imposing a prison term "does invite others to engage in similar conduct," he said.

He said that white-collar criminals should not be allowed to get away with crime, then make payments and get home detention where they can "watch reruns of 'Gunsmoke'" in their comfortable houses.

"There's an old saying that at least crime shouldn't pay," he said. "Without some sting of a sentence the message is, 'Crime does pay.'"

Hughes will spend 60 days at the Northeast Ohio Correctional Center, then three years of probation, including a year of home detention on electronic monitoring.

Advertise with us

Hughes and Booker were indicted in 2018 after a lengthy investigation by the FBI.

The first public notice of the investigation came in 2014 when prosecutors moved to forfeit more than $700,000 from Hughes.

Other medical professionals have been ensnared as well, including John Johnson, a Hollidaysburg pain clinic doctor, and Robert Fetchero, an osteopath from Jeannette. Johnson went to federal prison, and Fetchero, along with other doctors in Florida and Indiana, paid hundreds of thousands of dollars to settle civil claims brought by the Justice Department accusing them of receiving kickbacks for referrals to Hughes. The case against Booker is pending.