A federal judge on Monday issued several orders to move forward proceedings in the long-stalled death penalty case against Robert Bowers, the Tree of Life shooting suspect.
In a conference call with the parties, U.S. District Judge Donetta Ambrose said it's time to get the case moving now that COVID-19 restrictions are being lifted and ordered that the defense will have until Oct. 1 to file official notice if it intends to seek an insanity defense.
Under the federal rules of criminal procedure, lawyers who intend to assert an insanity defense must notify the U.S. attorney's office in writing as part of the pre-trial motions.
The judge also ordered the parties to set a date for the completion of review of all the physical evidence in the case. She said she expects that the review will be done by the end of September.
The Bowers defense team has repeatedly requested delays in the case because the lawyers have said the pandemic restrictions have hindered their ability to collect information, conduct interviews, talk to their client and do research.
Oct. 27 will mark three years since the mass shooting that left 11 worshippers dead.
Read More
The Justice Department is seeking the federal death penalty. The defense — two public defenders and a California anti-death penalty lawyer — are asking for a plea deal that will spare Mr. Bowers' life. At least one of the three congregations at Tree of Life has also requested that the Justice Department accept a plea.
Judge Ambrose last week rejected several defense motions to suppress evidence collected after the shootings. She has yet to rule on several others and said she will hold hearings on those. She requested that the defense consult its witnesses regarding potential dates for hearings on those motions but said she expects to conduct the hearings on two successive dates in September.
The defense team has filed numerous motions challenging the validity of FBI search warrants granted after the shootings by U.S. Magistrate Judge Robert Mitchell. Such challenges are usually made on the grounds that the warrants are too broad and give law enforcement too much discretion to rummage through someone's life.
The Bowers lawyers made that argument, too, but Judge Ambrose rejected it.
In one challenge, the lawyers said that searches of Mr. Bowers' home and vehicle failed to establish probable cause and lacked specifics. The judge disagreed, saying the warrants were not overly broad but sought to find evidence and establish a motive for the shootings in that Mr. Bowers is charged with hate crimes in targeting Jews.
A second motion challenged an FBI warrant for medical records pertaining to Mr. Bowers' commercial drivers' license as a trucker. The judge said the warrant was sufficiently limited in scope and noted that the FBI said that Mr. Bowers' mental health will be at issue at any trial, so medical records are germane.
Judge Ambrose also allowed a search of one of Mr. Bowers' email accounts to stand, saying the FBI affidavit supporting the warrant laid out the details of the shooting and made note that during the attack Mr. Bowers said he wanted to kill Jews.
The judge said she will hold a hearing, however, on the seizure of a second email account from December 2007 to March 2008. She said she will also hear arguments on a motion to suppress statements that Mr. Bowers made at the scene of the shooting and at the hospital where he was treated for gunshot wounds.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.