Municipal police departments are one step closer to being able to use radar on the roads.

On Tuesday, the state Senate passed a bill that would allow the departments to use radar to enforce speed limits.

Pennsylvania is the only state that forbids the use of radar by local police.

The bill, sponsored by state Sen. Mario Scavello, a Republican, stipulates a municipality cannot make more than 10% of its budget in speeding tickets, must pass an ordinance and train officers on using the devices. Local departments also must engage in periodic testing and set calibration standards for the radar guns.

Advertise with us

Allegheny County police Superintendent Christopher Kearns said the department would pursue radar for speed enforcement. He said it often gets complaints about speeding on thoroughfares such as Corrigan Drive in South Park and Lake Shore Drive in North Park. Having radar devices would help with this issue, he said.

“It would be a tool that would allow speed enforcement,” Superintendent Kearns said. “It would probably be easier than the current methods.”

Read More

Ross police Detective Sgt. Brian Kohlhepp said the department would welcome “any measure we can use that better protects the traveling public” and ensure “everyone being able to get to their destination with as little incident as possible.”

“Whatever tool we can use to help to do that better and more efficiently is a good thing, and radar would definitely be in that category of something that we could employ to try and make travel on the roadways safer,” Sgt. Kohlhepp said.

The use of radar guns won’t dramatically change how the department does speed enforcement, according to Sgt. Kohlhepp.

Advertise with us

“This is simply an easier way for us to continue to do what we’ve already done and we can do so with more efficient manpower, which allows us to dedicate resources to other important areas,” Sgt. Kohlhepp said.

This bill is not what it seems, said James Sikorski, Pennsylvania advocate for the National Motorists Association.

“The bill permits underposted speed limits and tickets barely above them,” Mr. Sikorski said. “Federal and state laws say to post the speed limits at the 85th percentile, so why is that not being done in Pennsylvania? This bill would criminalize safe drivers who are going to work and doing essential activities.”

Mr. Sikorski also cited federal studies that have shown that speed limits have little to do with how fast people drive.

“Most speed limits are underposted by eight to 16 mph and low-speed limits can lead to more crashes,” Mr. Sikorski said. “So much for safety. This is being done for revenue. PennDOT also has said for years that Pennsylvania roads are the safest in history, all that without having radar.”

Advertise with us

The push for radar on the local level has been a battle in Harrisburg over the past few years. The state police have voiced opposition, said Mr. Kearns.

“There was a fear that departments would utilize radar as a revenue-generating tool, the classic speed traps that they use for radar would lead to that,” Mr. Kearns explained.

Shelia Dunn, communications director for the National Motorists Association, said that no matter what the NMA “will be against the bill because it does promote speed traps, especially for smaller communities, and it also creates an environment where cities realize they can make money off the backs of motorists through taxation by citation so it’s very heinous that way.”

Out-of-state drivers are the most at risk because they are unfamiliar with roads and speed limits, according to Ms. Dunn. Being out-of-state also makes it harder to fight tickets, plus the three points added to a license will increase the cost of that driver’s auto insurance.

“Of course, I think most people want to heed the speed limits because they don’t want to get tickets, but to be predatory like that is really, really frustrating,” she said.

Advertise with us

Speed traps also don’t help towns, Ms. Dunn continued.

“If there are all these speed traps outside of town people won’t want to go there anymore, and then your economy gets hurt and that's really frustrating too for business owners,” Ms. Dunn said. “So, there are a lot of ramifications. It’s not just about safety — it’s also about a lot of other things. And this isn’t really about safety — it’s about making money.”

Monroeville police chief Kenneth Cole said he’s in favor of how the Senate crafted its bill.

“There’s always been some concern that police departments would use it as a moneymaker, that would be nothing further from the truth in Monroeville,” Chief Cole said. “We would use it for citizen complaints, specifically, neighborhood streets. It would make it a lot easier to support speed limits or to address those complaints.”

AAA also is in support of the bill because it meets five out of six of the company’s criteria, said Theresa Podguski, director of legislative affairs for AAA East Central.

Advertise with us

“AAA supports any local police radar legislation as long as it has protections,” Ms. Podguski said. “I think that because the legislation has most of these protections that it will be beneficial and help with traffic safety.”

According to Mr. Scavello, speeding is the leading contributor to fatal crashes. Thirty percent of fatal speeding crashes occur on local roads.

“Here in the 40th Senate District, we’ve seen at least 15 pedestrian deaths over the past 20 years where speed was a factor, and just one is too many,” Mr. Scavello said in a statement. “This legislation will save lives.”

The bill has been sent to the House for consideration.

A Pittsburgh police spokesperson said the department would have to review the decision before commenting.

Hannah Wyman: hwyman@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1255