Extra security is expected as jury selection gets underway Monday for the trial of a Beaver County man charged with the shooting death of his childhood friend.

Sheldon Jeter Jr., 23, of Aliquippa, is accused of killing 30-year-old Tyric Pugh in Aliquippa in May 2020. Jeter is also one of several people investigators have questioned in the high-profile Rachael DelTondo homicide case.

DelTondo, 33, a teacher in Aliquippa, was killed in her parents’ driveway on Mother’s Day 2018. No suspects have been named in the case.

Beaver County Sheriff Tony Guy said security will be increased at the Beaver County courthouse for the trial into the Pugh slaying.

Advertise with us

“We are expecting a fair amount of interest in this trial. So we will be prepared for that,” Guy told Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV. “We have security apparatus to get in the building, x-ray machines, magnetometers. There will be extra deputies working this case more than a normal trial.”

In the Pugh case, police said Jeter had gone for ice cream with Pugh the day of the shooting, May 15, 2020, and surveillance video showed the suspect’s vehicle leaving the scene of the homicide on Kiehl Street shortly after the man was killed. Pugh had been shot several times and was pronounced dead at the scene, police said.

Investigators visited the address listed on Pugh’s ID and encountered Jeter, who also lived there. He told them he was with Pugh earlier that day, but authorities said he gave contradictory statements regarding the time he left his home before Pugh was shot and the last time he was with him.

Jeter’s defense attorney, Michael Santicola, maintains that his client is innocent and said the two are “good friends” and “have known each other their entire lives.”

In the DelTondo case, a state grand jury investigation into the murder was expected to wrap up soon.

Advertise with us

Jeter, a onetime Aliquippa High School football player, had romantic ties with DelTondo. A leaked police report documenting a late-night meeting the two had in a car while he was still a teen had led to her suspension from Pennsylvania Cyber Charter School.

DelTondo was shot multiple times at close range and was the killer’s intended target, police said. She was alone when she was gunned down.

The slaying was the subject of the TV crime news show “48 Hours” in May 2019 — called “What happened to Rachael DelTondo?” — that took a closer look at the investigation and mystery behind the shooting death.