This story was updated at 4:30 p.m. on May 17.

Felipe Vazquez’s sexual assault trial began Monday in Westmoreland County with prosecutors framing the case as a professional athlete abusing his star power by exploiting a young girl through social media, while the defense sought to cast the teen as the manipulator.

The former Pirates relief pitcher is accused of sexually assaulting a 13-year-old girl in 2017 and exchanging sexually explicit phone communications with her until 2019. The Venezuela native, 29, has been suspended by the team and Major League Baseball since the allegations came to light two years ago. He also faces charges in Florida for similar allegations regarding the same girl.

Westmoreland County Assistant District Attorney James Lazar told the jury in his opening statement that society casts athletes as heroes and media turns them into sex symbols. He added that technology and social media can desensitize communication.

Advertise with us

“With children, that impersonal contact can just heighten their vulnerability,” Mr. Lazar said.

The two began talking when the girl reached out to Mr. Vazquez on Instagram in summer 2017 to wish him a happy birthday. He responded and asked her to talk to him on Snapchat, Mr. Lazar told the court.

She told him that she was 17 years old and would be turning 18 in September — on the day she was actually turning 14.

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette does not identify alleged victims of sexual assault.

Mr. Lazar said Mr. Vazquez’s communications with the alleged victim showed he repeatedly referred to her as “kid” and told her that she needed to grow up.

Advertise with us

But defense attorney Gary Gerson said his client was deceived by a “liar” who led a secret life that she hid from her family.

Mr. Gerson told the jury that they shouldn’t believe that she was a naive child who was groomed by Mr. Vazquez. He added that Mr. Vazquez genuinely believed she was an adult because she sent him a photo of a fake ID that appeared to show her age was 18.

“What this case is really about is reverse grooming,” Mr. Gerson said. “This is a case of a child grooming an adult.”

In his opening statement, Mr. Gerson read multiple explicit text messages that the girl sent to Mr. Vazquez as he tried to show the jury that she was the instigator of many of the interactions, which mainly occurred over text and social media.

Mr. Gerson also said Mr. Vazquez, as a pro athlete, was used to women coming onto him online, referring to him as a “physical specimen” who was naturally attractive to the opposite sex.

Advertise with us

The girl used makeup and clothing to make herself appear older than she really was, Mr. Gerson said, contrasting the photos of a young, awkward adolescent that the prosecution showed to the jury.

“Felipe never saw these photos” of her, he said. “What he saw was a made-up face. A woman.”

Mr. Vazquez was denied bail in September 2019 because Mount Pleasant District Judge Charles D. Moore believed he was a flight risk. He has been held since then in the Westmoreland County Prison.

He faces 24 felony charges in Westmoreland County, including child pornography, statutory sexual assault, unlawful contact with a minor and corruption of minors, court records show. He is also charged with indecent assault, a misdemeanor.

The victim’s mother testified that her family were big Pirates fans and would go to at least five games a year. Her family in 2016 became acquainted with Starling Marte, then an outfielder for the Pirates, after the daughter messaged him on social media.

Advertise with us

The family would often stand outside the players’ exit at PNC Park and interact with Mr. Marte and other athletes as they drove away from the stadium, the mother said.

One day, as they waited near the exit, Mr. Vazquez flashed his headlights on and off, puzzling the woman because she was unaware that her daughter had any connection to him.

She said her daughter at the time was making “bad choices,” secretly going to parties and smoking marijuana.

The victim testified that she first messaged Mr. Vazquez on Instagram to wish him a happy birthday, and that day he added her on Snapchat through the contact information on her Instagram page. She called Mr. Vazquez a “huge star.”

“I was excited and thought it was pretty cool,” the girl, now 17, testified.

Advertise with us

In the weeks following, they exchanged phone numbers and he began asking for nude photos, she said. At first she declined, but he continued asking and she sent him a photo of her chest and butt. He also sent pictures of his penis.

“I felt, like, so cool,” she said about talking to him. She said they wouldn’t interact on a regular basis.

When her parents were taking her older sister to move into college in 2017, she told Mr. Vazquez that she would be home alone.

She said she thought he wasn’t coming over, but after she exited the shower, she noticed several texts and calls from Mr. Vazquez indicating that he was outside her house.

The girl testified that she did not usually wear makeup except mascara and bronzer, and she did not put on any makeup when she exited her home to meet Mr. Vazquez in his red Ford Mustang that day.

Advertise with us

At first, she brought her dog out with her because she was scared, she said, but the pitcher told her to put the dog inside. When she came back out and entered his car, they talked about a friend of hers that Mr. Vazquez had blocked on Snapchat.

Then he picked her up and placed her on his lap so that her back was against the driver’s side window, she said.

He started to kiss her and she “tried” to kiss back, but he told her she needed “to put more tongue in it,” she said.

She began crying as she told the court that he pulled her pants down, took off his pants and penetrated her, but he was only able to insert the tip of his penis.

After a minute, he placed her back into the passenger seat and they sat in silence for five minutes, she testified. Then he said he had an afternoon game to play and had to leave. When she exited the car, he smacked her butt.

Advertise with us

“I just felt numb,” she said. Later, he texted her an emoji of a smiling, drooling face.

Their communications were on and off for two more years because he would stop texting her if she didn’t send him nude photos, she said. When she didn’t show up for a planned meeting in Orlando, he called her a “little kid” and told her she needed to “grow up.”

They didn’t meet with each other again, but the explicit nature of their messages began to escalate, and each of them exchanged videos showing them masturbating.

After she and her parents moved to Florida in 2019, her mother discovered some of the messages when she left her phone out while using the bathroom. Mr. Vazquez’s contact was listed as “Justin (School)” in the girl’s phone.

Her mother said she was shocked and questioned the girl, who then broke down in tears and told the mother most of what had happened with Mr. Vazquez. The woman called the sexual abuse hotline three times while she tried to figure out how to handle the situation, she said.

Advertise with us

She also confiscated her daughter’s phone and texted Mr. Vazquez, telling him that she was the mother of the girl he’d been speaking with. She sent him a screenshot of their text messages, which included photos of him wearing only a towel and in his underwear.

“I guess your career means nothing to you?” she messaged him. “She is a minor and you are 28.”

Mr. Vazquez did not respond.

Upon cross examination, Mr. Gerson focused on the girl’s delinquent activities and noted that there was no way Mr. Vazquez would have known that the text was truly from the mother, saying it could have been a “spoof” or a prank.

He also pointed out that Mr. Vazquez never attempted to flee or offer the family money to stay quiet about the relationship.

Advertise with us

Before the girl could be cross-examined by the defense, Common Pleas Judge Scott O. Mears adjourned the session because the attorneys wanted to discuss evidentiary issues surrounding exhibits of the explicit messages, photos and videos. The delay caused by the discussion would have left little time for cross-examination, he noted.

The case is set to resume Tuesday at 9 a.m.

Additional charges connected to Mr. Vazquez’s contact with the girl are pending in Florida and Missouri, with allegations surfacing last year that he sent pornographic material to the girl when he was in St. Louis in 2017.

Until his arrest, Mr. Vazquez — an All-Star in 2018 and 2019 — was a valuable member of the team’s pitching staff. He was the closer, or the pitcher who was sent into the game in late innings to preserve a victory. In 2019, before his arrest, he had a 5-1 record, 28 saves and an earned run average of 1.65.

Shortly after his arrest, MLB placed Mr. Vazquez on administrative leave and the league’s restricted list in accordance with league rules. That means he is not an active member of the Pirates roster, but the team would retain his rights if he is ever cleared to return to MLB.

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1869 and on Twitter: @MickStinelli.