A tax preparer in Clearfield County who prepared false income tax returns, lied about a previous conviction and then leaked information about a drug investigation while improperly serving on a federal grand jury will spend 27 months in federal prison for those crimes.

U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab imposed that term Wednesday on Kathy Billotte, 60, of Frenchville.

Billotte, a former postmaster, had pleaded guilty to aiding in the preparation of a false income tax return and lying to the government.

Billotte was a tax return preparer who ran KB Tax Services in Clearfield County and falsified returns for at least 15 people from 2013 through 2017, according to the criminal investigation division of the IRS.

Advertise with us

As a result, her customers received refunds to which they were not entitled.

In regard to the count to which she pleaded guilty, she prepared a return for someone identified as "T.G." on which she falsely reported that TG operated a business and incurred business expenses. The return also inflated unreimbursed business expenses and charitable donations.

The total tax loss for the 15 clients was $193,000, which Judge Schwab ordered Billotte to pay to the IRS.

Federal prosecutors brought the tax case in March 2020 and she pleaded guilty in July.

But while the tax investigation was pending, Billotte was summoned to serve as a federal grand juror in Johnstown in early 2019. Prosecutors said she lied on a jury questionnaire by saying she had no prior criminal convictions when in fact she is a federal felon. She had pleaded guilty in federal court in 1999 to fraudulently obtaining U.S. postal money orders and a related count and received probation. But as a felon, she was not qualified to serve on a federal grand jury.

Advertise with us

While the grand jury was being qualified, Billotte told a magistrate judge, Keith Pesto, that she had been arrested for a federal case but claimed she was a victim. When the judge said, "You weren't convicted of anything?" she said, "Right."

She served on the grand jury panel that handed up an indictment against 39 people in a drug ring following a wiretap investigation. After the grand jury session was done but before anyone was arrested, Billotte told her daughter about the case and word got out into the community, said Assistant U.S. Attorney Cindy Chung.

Grand jurors are specifically told by judges that the proceedings are secret.

The U.S. attorney's office filed charges of false statements to the government last December and she pleaded to both counts in January.

"The defendant’s conduct with regard to both counts reflect a blatant disregard and lack of respect for the authority of the court," Ms. Chung wrote in a sentencing memo. "Moreover, the defendant’s false statements caused her to be improperly seated on the grand jury which, in turn, led to harmful real-world consequences in that she then unlawfully disclosed information related to the indictment of an extensive drug conspiracy."

Advertise with us

Prior to sentencing, Billotte and her lawyer asked Judge Schwab to depart downwardly from sentencing guidelines, characterizing the grand jury lies as "minor" offenses.

The judge rejected that argument.

"Defendant’s false statement to Magistrate Judge Pesto thus resulted in a convicted felon being seated on a federal grand jury panel, a violation of the integrity of the grand jury panel, and not a 'minor' offense," he wrote in denying the request for leniency.

The judge also took her to task for leaking information once she was on the grand jury by telling her daughter about an acquaintance who was among those indicted, among other disclosures.

Judge Schwab said he found Billotte's leak to be "especially disturbing."

Advertise with us

"Fortunately for [Billotte], no one was hurt as a result of her criminal conduct, but others, including law enforcement, easily could have been injured," he wrote.

He also said her actions in preparing false tax returns was egregious in that she repeatedly violated the tax laws.