A New Castle police officer testified Tuesday in the federal trial of a former colleague charged with using excessive force that a suspect was no longer resisting when the former officer repeatedly smashed the man's face against the floor during an arrest.
"Ronnie, I got it," Officer Pete Mendicino said he told Ronald Williams as Mr. Williams slammed Perry Lawry's head against a hardwood floor.
Officer Mendicino said he had earlier delivered knee strikes to subdue Mr. Lawry and was trying to handcuff him as he knelt when Mr. Williams grabbed Mr. Lawry by the head, shouted expletives and pounded him four times until he went limp.
The incident was captured on a cell phone video, the central piece of evidence at the trial.
"I figured I had to speak up so he would stop doing that," Officer Mendicino told a federal court jury. "I was concerned that [Mr. Lawry] was going to suffer severe injury or even death."
Under later questioning, Officer Mendicino, a field training officer, said Mr. Lawry was kneeling on the floor and not actively fighting police when the assault occurred.
Read More
"Mr. Lawry wasn't giving us any resistance," he said.
Mr. Williams is charged with one count of deprivation of civil rights. He is one of only a handful of officers to face federal charges over excessive force in this district in the past six years. All the others were convicted.
Mr. Williams was indicted in 2019 in connection with the April 23, 2018 incident at a New Castle apartment.
Prosecutors say, Mr. Williams, at 6 feet, 4 inches and nearly 300 pounds, used unnecessary force in arresting Mr. Lawry, a much smaller man, after Mr. Lawry had been subdued.
Police responded that day to a dispatch call for a domestic dispute after Mr. Lawry's girlfriend said he was drunk and had assaulted her juvenile son.
Officer Mendicino arrived first and found Mr. Lawry lying on the kitchen floor, drunk and incoherent. The officer said he grabbed Mr. Lawry and lifted him to his feet. He said Mr. Lawry then pulled away from him and ran toward a counter with large knives on it.
Officer Mendicino grabbed him, the two grappled and fell to the ground. Officer Mendicino said kneed Mr. Lawry in the torso to get him under control.
At that moment Mr. Williams arrived and joined the fight.
Mr. Williams used his Taser several times to no effect, and the officers eventually subdued Mr. Lawry.
Officer Mendicino said he had put one handcuff on Mr. Lawry's right wrist and was trying to grab his left hand, but Mr. Lawry was lying on top of his arm. At that point, he said, Mr. Williams yanked Mr. Lawry's head from behind, lifted him up and bashed his face on the floor. The video appears to show him grabbing Mr. Lawry by the hair.
After the third strike, Officer Mendicino said "Ronnie, I got it," meaning to stop the assault. He said Mr. Williams delivered another blow after he said that.
Audio from the cell phone video, shot by the juvenile son, records the loud thumping sounds of Mr. Lawry's face impacting the floor and the son saying, "Don't kill him!" to Mr. Williams and later "Jesus Christ. I think he's dead" after Lawry stops moving.
Officer Mendicino said Mr. Williams wrote the incident report but that his account was not accurate.
Mr. Williams had written that Mr. Lawry had crawled toward the counter where the knives lay during the scuffle, but at no point did Mr. Lawry crawl in the direction of the knives, Officer Mendicino said.
Mr. Williams also wrote that "I did grab the male by the back of his shoulder's [sic] and gave him three thrusts shoving his chest and head into the floor until he stop [sic] resisting and handcuffs could be placed on the male."
Officer Mendicino said Mr. Williams actually grabbed Mr. Lawry's head, not his shoulders.
Officer Mendicino also said he told Mr. Williams after the arrest that Mr. Lawry had earlier run toward the counter with the knives, but that happened before Mr. Williams got there. He said that when Mr. Williams slammed Mr. Lawry, "he was never resisting."
A nurse practitioner testified that Mr. Lawry needed 23 stitches in his face to close his wounds.
The trial will continue Wednesday before U.S. District Judge William Stickman IV.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.