Lawyers for two men from Pennsylvania and West Virginia charged with conspiring to assault police with pepper spray during the Jan. 6 Capitol insurrection said Tuesday that neither is a risk to the public and should be freed pending trial, but federal prosecutors say the men planned for violence, carried it out and should remain locked up.
Thomas Hogan, a federal judge in the District of Columbia, heard the debate and watched video of the incident at a hearing today for George Tanios, 39, of Morgantown, and Julian Khater, 32, of State College, but ran out of time and said he’d listen to more arguments next week.
Mr. Tanios and Mr. Khater are accused of spraying officers during the riots and causing the police line to collapse as the insurrection began.
One officer, Brian Sicknick, later died, although the two suspects are not charged with his death.
Authorities initially said that Mr. Khater had used bear spray on police, but prosecutors said it was actually pepper spray. Assistant U.S. Attorney Gilead Light said Mr. Tanios had bought bear spray the day before and had it in his backpack, and during the riot Mr. Khater is heard saying to Mr. Tanios “give me that bear [expletive]” while reaching into Mr. Tanios’ backpack.
But Mr. Light said he actually used a smaller can of pepper spray on the police.
Read More
Regardless of which spray was actually used, he said it was obvious that the two planned for a violent encounter and then assaulted police.
The fact that they had bear spray points to their plot, he said, and supports the conspiracy charge.
“Why are they buying bear spray to go to a city?” he asked. “It’s an uncontested fact that there are no bears in downtown D.C.”
He also said that after Mr. Khater requested the bear spray, Mr. Tanios is heard telling him, “No, it’s too early,” an indication that they had planned to use it when the time was right.
Video from various sources shows Mr. Khater spraying pepper spray at the police, a fact that his lawyer, Joseph Tacopina, did not dispute. But he said his client was responding in self-defense to having been sprayed first by police.
“It’s a spontaneous act, a reactionary act,” he said.
He also said 18 family members have vouched for his client, saying he’s peaceful, wouldn’t hurt anyone and had once planned to become a sheriff’s deputy.
“He’s not a risk, not a danger,” Mr. Tacopina said.
He further argued that other accused rioters engaged in much more violent conduct, such as punching police officers, and have been released on bond.
Elizabeth Gross, a federal public defender, made a similar argument for Mr. Tanios, the owner of a sandwich shop in Morgantown. She presented two witnesses who said Mr. Tanios is a family man whose life revolved around his business and his children. Ms. Gross ran out of time, however, before she could present more argument for his release.
Prosecutors had previously argued that Mr. Tanios could be a flight risk as well as a danger, fearing he might travel to Lebanon, where his mother, Maguy Tanios, was born. Mrs. Tanios had previously said she had escaped war-torn Lebanon to start a new life in America.
But Judge Hogan said he’s not concerned that Mr. Tanios is a flight risk.
He said he’ll rewatch the videos, hear more from the lawyers and any witnesses on May 6, and hopefully make a decision.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.