Cheron Shelton, acquitted in the massacre of five people at a Wilkinsburg cookout in 2016, was sentenced Thursday to eight years in federal prison for possession of a gun and ammunition unrelated to the shooting.

U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab imposed that term, agreed to by both parties as part of a plea deal, and also ordered him to be on probation for three years after he gets out.

Shelton, of Homewood, said little in a video sentencing except to request that he be allowed to participate in welding training while in prison. The judge said he would recommend it, noting that the country is in great need of welders and that the trade would allow Shelton to become a productive citizen.

A federal grand jury had indicted Shelton in 2020 in connection with a rifle found at his mother’s house during the investigation of the mass killing on March 9, 2016.

Advertise with us

The charge came two weeks after an Allegheny County Common Pleas jury acquitted him of the murders. Charges against his co-defendant, Robert Thomas, were dismissed.

Shelton isn’t allowed to have guns or ammunition because he has a prior drug conviction in state court in 2010.

His lawyer, James Paulick, said he and his client decided to accept a deal with the U.S. attorney’s office under which he would serve eight years. Had he not accepted the deal, Mr. Paulick said, the government had indicated it would file additional charges involving more ammunition that could have resulted in a prison term of up to 20 years.

Shelton’s mother, sister and father all spoke briefly on his behalf by video.

“He’s a good person and he would like to get his life back on track,” said his mother, Desdrene Smith.

Advertise with us

His sister, Brittany Shelton, said her brother is a “good male figure and father figure” and asked for leniency, although the sentence was already set ahead of time as part of the plea.

His father, Robert Shelton, blamed himself for his son’s plight.

“That should be me sitting there [in jail] because I’ve been a terrible father,” he told the judge. “I’m sorry, I wish I could have been a better role model.”

The gun charge stems from the investigation of the murder case. A few days after the killings, law enforcement officers searched Desdrene Smith’s house in Homewood and found a .22-caliber rifle and ammunition. The gun had been reported stolen in Uniontown. Mrs. Smith said the gun was not hers and must be her son’s, according to prior testimony.

A thumbprint on the gun matched Shelton. In addition, surveillance footage showed him at the house on March 9.

Advertise with us

Police charged him on March 25 with receiving stolen property and later with the homicides.

The .22-caliber rifle is not the same weapon as used in the murders. That gun was an AK-47 assault rifle, police have said, and it was never recovered.

Shelton had been charged with the murder of five people: Brittany Powell, 27; her brother, Jerry Michael Shelton, 35; her sister, Chanetta Powell, 25, who was eight months pregnant, and cousins Tina Shelton, 37, and Shada Mahone, 26. Three others were wounded: Lamont Powell, Tonjia Stone Cunningham and John Ellis Jr.

Mr. Ellis died last September of complications from his injuries.

His mother, Aleta Livsey, said Thursday that Shelton should have been convicted in the first trial. She said the federal sentence brings her no relief.

Advertise with us

“It’s not going to bring them back,” she said.

But she acknowledged that the federal term will keep Shelton locked up for now.

“At least he’s not out on the street where he can hurt someone else,” she said. “He’ll pay for what he’s done. It’s not enough, but it’s something.”